Amtrak rail travel growing fast, but it's profitable on few routes

2013-03-04T00:00:00Z Amtrak rail travel growing fast, but it's profitable on few routesThe Washington Post The Washington Post Arizona Daily Star
March 04, 2013 12:00 am  • 

WASHINGTON - Perhaps sparked by highway congestion or the hassle of air travel, Amtrak's passenger rail service has been the nation's fastest-growing mode of transportation, according to a new report that urges Congress to push forward with a coordinated national rail plan.

The government-subsidized railway carried a record 31.2 million people last year, a 55 percent increase since 1997, according to a study by the Brookings Institution.

The study, released on Friday, came a day after congressional leaders said they planned to craft a major funding reauthorization for railroads later this year.

Amtrak turns a profit on only four of its more than 40 routes, the study showed, all of them in the Northeast corridor, a shortcoming that raised the hackles of some Republicans in the last Congress.

For more than a year, Rep. John Mica, R.-Fla., then chairman of the House Transportation Committee, repeatedly called Amtrak a "Soviet-style railroad" before relenting to concede that it might be acceptable if only it could turn a profit. He suggested selling off the Northeast corridor service to private firms.

Mica's successor as chair of the influential committee, Rep. Bill Shuster, R.-Pa., struck a more conciliatory tone in a speech to state transportation officials on Thursday.

"I think there's a need for passenger rail in this country," Shuster told The American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials, suggesting that Amtrak needed to "get closer to break-even."

He said the Obama administration should narrow its plan to begin building a national high-speed rail system, focusing on the Northeast corridor first.

Washington ranks behind New York and ahead of Philadelphia as the second-busiest Amtrak hub city, and the four profitable routes in the system serve that corridor.

The Brookings study showed that nearly 90 percent of the ridership increase since 1997 has been trips of less than 400 miles, generating a positive operating balance of $47 million in 2011. Longer routes carried the rest of the passengers and lost $614 million, the study said. Overall, Amtrak receives a $1.5 billion federal subsidy each year.

Almost two-thirds of the rail line's ridership came from 10 major metropolitan areas, all but Chicago on the East or West Coast.

"Amtrak is too often considered a big, bloated bureaucracy that depends heavily on federal subsidies and is no longer relevant to the technologically oriented metropolitan economies of today," said Robert Puentes, who co-authored the report. "But the fact is that Amtrak is reinventing itself through its short-haul routes and with the support of states, which are helping upgrade tracks, operate routes and redevelop stations."

The study concluded that while continued federal support and development of a national rail plan were vital to Amtrak's continued success, the rail line must build stronger alliances with freight rail companies that own much of the track on which it operates, and turn to state governments for greater support and innovative funding sources.

BY THE NUMBERS

Tucson and Phoenix are on Amtrak's Sunset Limited Route, which runs 1,995 miles between Lousiana and California. Sunset Limited carried a total of 101,217 passengers in 2012, a drop of 18.4 percent since 1997. It had an operating deficit of $39.1 million last year, according to the Brookings Institution.

Tucson

1997: 23,524

2012: 23,896

Total Amtrak passengers (boardings and alightings)

Percent change: +1.6 percent

Number of Amtrak stations: 1

Phoenix-Mesa-Scottsdale

1997: 0

2012: 10,804

Total passengers (boardings and alightings)

Number of Amtrak stations: 1

Source: 2013 Brookings Institution study

Copyright 2014 Arizona Daily Star. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Featured businesses

View more...

Event Calendar

Today's events | Add an event

Most viewed: