Ask Amy for May 10: Psychologist needs to heal herself

2014-05-10T00:00:00Z 2014-07-03T11:09:46Z Ask Amy for May 10: Psychologist needs to heal herselfBy Amy Dickinson Tribune Content Agency Arizona Daily Star

DEAR AMY: My sister is a clinical psychologist. Recently I introduced her to a close friend of mine.

My friend hosted a gathering for Easter and invited us both. I could not make it, but my sister did.

I received a call from my friend afterward. She was very upset. Apparently my sister took it upon herself to give unsolicited advice to some of the partygoers that she had just met.

She jumped in when a child had a meltdown, chastising the parent and reprimanding the grandmother, causing an angry response from the grandmother.

My sister then insulted another individual she just met by criticizing this person’s method of counseling in her own practice. I was told that many at the party were shocked and insulted by her lack of tact and social graces.

My sister makes a habit of telling people how to conduct their lives and aggressively pushes her opinions onto others under the guise of “just trying to help.” She has alienated many family members over the years, asking personal questions to those she just met (for instance, asking young people about their sexual practices and birth control methods and then giving advice that is not wanted).

She seems to be especially intolerant of small children and openly criticizes the parents in front of everyone (she doesn’t have kids). When relationships with loved ones are not going her way, she breaks down and cries like she is being mistreated.

She says, “That’s just how I am. You need to change how you feel.” What should I say (or do) to get through to her? She is very intelligent, but never admits any wrongdoing on her part. — Upset Sister

DEAR SISTER: Your sister should know well through her professional training that people don’t actually need to change the way they feel.

People do frequently need to change the way they act, however. Let’s start with your sister.

Drawing on her expertise with how to deal with children, she will be familiar with the concept of “natural consequences.”

A natural consequence of her intolerant and aggressive behavior is for people not to spend time with her. I assume your mutual friend will stop inviting her to events (and your friend, not you, should handle this).

You are in a position to influence your sister by telling her, “I love and respect you, but your habit of leaping over boundaries and injecting your views is tough to take. I don’t like it, and it is affecting our relationship.”

You cannot change your sister. You can only encourage her to work on her own personal growth, perhaps in therapy.

I’ll pass along a quote I have taped to my computer: “Unsolicited advice is always self-serving.”

DEAR AMY: Last weekend was the beautiful wedding of my oldest daughter and new son-in-law.

As we recover from the festivities it was noted there were several no-shows. I totally understand that life gets busy. When you RSVP in February for an April wedding, all intentions are to show up. Then life happens. This leaves the bride holding the doggie bag.

Catered meals for weddings are expensive. If 10 or 20 people don’t show, this adds up. If the caterer has a heads-up even a week before the event, quantities and prices can be adjusted.

As wedding season approaches could you remind your readers that their presence will be missed but we don’t need the leftovers or expense. Send your regrets ahead of time. — Happy MOB in Portland

DEAR MOB: Sometimes people feel they’ve done their job as a guest by responding to an invitation in a timely fashion. But you raise a very important point: When plans change, notify the hosts, giving them time to adjust their plans.

DEAR AMY: I’m responding to the crazy letter from “Devastated,” who was involved in a brief relationship with a guy whose story didn’t stick together.

One can never overestimate the pathology of a liar. Normal people who act in good faith are perfect patsies for this kind of individual. She should thank her lucky stars he didn’t take her for any money. — Mimi

DEAR MIMI: Absolutely.

DEAR AMY: How about that letter from “Devastated”? This was someone who was prepared to turn her life upside down after knowing a guy for a month.

I think you called it right: He’s a liar. She’s a mark.

What could she possibly be thinking? — Shocked

DEAR SHOCKED: If people thought more, we’d all have less to amuse us.

DEAR AMY: Recently, I had a relative’s teenage daughter come stay with me over a holiday weekend. She had been having issues with her parents and at school, so I thought this would give everyone a rest and a breather.

The teen is close to my older kids, and I thought they might be able to mentor and nurture her.

The entire weekend reminded me of the saying, “No good deed goes unpunished.”

I haven’t had that much drama in my house since my own daughter was a teenager — and to top it off, my own kids gave her alcohol when I wasn’t with them. I was truly disappointed when I found out.

I thought for sure that I had taught them to know better. When I tried to talk to them about it, they actually tried to defend it. They believe that it was better for them to buy her liquor and let her drink it supervised, rather than with strangers. Seriously?

It took someone coming into my house and staying for two days to upset the balance of the household.

Now I’m at a loss to explain to my two adult (ages 24 and 22) children why this was a colossal mess-up. They are adults and should know better, right?

Can you please give me some guidance? — Horrified

DEAR HORRIFIED: Your heart was in the right place, but your hubris seems to have overwhelmed your judgment.

You cannot take a troubled teenager into your house for a long weekend and “fix” her. You should expect her to behave the way she usually behaves, only in a new environment that offers new ways to act out and new co-conspirators.

You also should not have left her under the supervision of two young adults who have no parenting experience and questionable judgment.

You don’t need to continue to explain to your kids why what they did was wrong; unfortunately, many older adults also feel as they do about “supervised” underage drinking. This is why parents of teenagers need to be aware of the values and judgment of all of the people (parents as well as kids) their teens hang with.

DEAR AMY: “Worried” was a busy grad student working on a crisis hotline who was feeling overwhelmed and depressed.

I thought your advice to her was compassionate and correct: People who bring comfort also need comfort. I hope she takes your advice to see a therapist. — Social Worker

DEAR SOCIAL WORKER: Her life sounded draining and exhausting. Therapy would help her recharge her emotional batteries.

Contact Amy Dickinson via email:

Follow her on Twitter @askingamy or “like” her on Facebook. Amy Dickinson’s memoir, “The Mighty Queens of Freeville: A Mother, a Daughter and the Town that Raised Them” (Hyperion), is available in bookstores.

Copyright 2014 Arizona Daily Star. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.