Rosemont opponents seek injunction to block EIS release

2011-03-26T11:46:00Z 2011-03-28T19:25:54Z Rosemont opponents seek injunction to block EIS releaseTony Davis Arizona Daily Star
March 26, 2011 11:46 am  • 

By Tony Davis

> > Arizona Daily Star


> Opponents of the proposed Rosemont Mine are asking the U.S. 

> District Court to grant an injunction stopping the federal 

> government from publishing a Draft Environmental Impact statement 

> on the mine.


> The motion from two environmental groups and the company that 

> operates the pecan groves in Sahuarita asked a federal judge to 

> hold a hearing and to order that the U.S. Forest Service include a 

> more balanced representation of all sides to the Rosemont dispute 

> when it holds future meetings of outside officials on the 

> environmental statement.


> The motion, filed this month, is the latest move in the legal case 

> over a series of 24 meetings that the Forest Service held from 2009 

> through 2010 with officials of Pima County, Arizona Game and Fish 

> Department and other cooperative agencies on the draft 

> environmental document.

The opponents have already filed suit against the Forest Service. 

> The latest motion is to seek an injunction to block the EIS from 

> being released until a trial can be held on the lawsuit’s merits. 

> The motion was filed by the Farmers Investment Co, Save the Scenic 

> Santa Ritas and the Center for Biological Diversiy.


> The U.S. Justice Department declined immediate comment on the 

> injunction request. It is due to reply to the motion on April 11, 

> and the Rosemont opponents are due to reply on April 26. However, 

> the district court hasn’t yet approved this schedule, said Charles 

> Miller, a Justice Department spokesman.


> The lawsuit charges that the Forest Service illegally ran these 

> meetings with Rosemont officials and consultants present at 19 of 

> them, but not any organized opponents of the mine. Such an action 

> violates the Federal Advisory Committee Act (FACA), which requires 

> that advisory committee meetings be open to the public and that its 

> membership must balance all viewpoints on the mine, the lawsuit says.


> The federal law excludes advisory groups consisting only of 

> government officials and their representatives. But the injunction 

> requested cites a handbook written by the U.S. Council on 

> Environmental Quality that says the law applies when a group 

> including one or more non-government officials offers advice to a 

> lead agency on alternatives that should be included in an 

> environmental statement, the injunction request said.


> In a letter to the mine opponents on Jan. 14, Coronado National 

> Forest Supervisor Jim Upchurch wrote that the service doesn’t 

> consider the Rosemont committee an advisory group that is covered 

> by the FACA law. The main reason for Rosemont’s presence at the 

> meetings “has been and will be solely for the purpose of providing 

> and receiving relevant technical information about the project,” Upchurch wrote in that letter.


Copyright 2015 Arizona Daily Star. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

About this blog

Star reporter Tony Davis covers topics in this blog that you have read under his byline for more than 30 years in the Southwest: water, growth, sprawl, pollution, climate change, endangered species, mining, grazing and traffic.

To reach Tony call 806-7746 (office) or 349-0350 (cell) or write him at

What's Hot

What's Hot

Featured businesses

View more...

Deals, offers & events

View more... newsletters

Sign up for e-mail newsletters

Sports news and blog headlines, delivered nightly.

Midmorning update of local business headlines, daily.

Tucson-area obituaries, daily.

Receive the current day's weather forecast in your email!