Big changes to immigration bill fended off

Senators debate when border can be declared secure
2013-05-10T00:00:00Z Big changes to immigration bill fended offLisa Mascaro Mcclatchy Newspapers Arizona Daily Star
May 10, 2013 12:00 am  • 

WASHINGTON - After eight hours of debate, the bipartisan Senate immigration bill emerged mostly intact Thursday, despite Republican-led efforts to make substantial alterations in the first of what is certain to be many long committee meetings to work through the 844-page proposal.

Senators on the Judiciary Committee spent most of the day on a question that has baffled immigration reformers: how to determine when the border with Mexico would be declared secure. The answer is crucial, because only then would the legalization process start for the estimated 11 million people in this country illegally.

Under the bill, the border was to be considered secure after the Department of Homeland Security had a plan that could halt 90 percent of the illegal crossings at three hot spots.

Republicans argued that without an even tougher standard, there would be no guarantee that authorities could prevent another wave of illegal immigration. Democrats countered that many of the Republican proposals were too costly or set unrealistic goals, making it unlikely the legalization process could ever begin.

The committee, which is controlled by Democrats, unanimously agreed to a modest but significant change: requiring a plan to stop 90 percent of illegal crossings along the entire southern border.

By day's end, senators had dispatched with 32 of 300 proposed amendments.

An overflow crowd, some wearing Statue of Liberty hats, waited in line for a seat in the audience. Many were supporters of an immigration overhaul, including people brought to the U.S. as minors who are now adults.

"My parents are hard-working people who deserve a chance to come forward and stop fearing that one day they will be caught," said Cynthia Domenzain, 20, of Scottsdale, who came to this country as a child more than a decade ago. "We want a better tomorrow."

The bill, which grew by a few dozen pages with the first amendment, is complex in both politics and policy.

It would require the federal government to gain almost total control of the border, authorizing money for drones, Customs and Border Protection officers and prosecution of illegal entries. New guest-worker programs would be established, particularly for low-skilled workers, and employers would be required to verify the legal status of all employees.

In exchange, people now in the country without legal status would be eligible for provisional status if they paid fees, fines and taxes. They could gain legal residency 10 years after the border was declared secure. After 13 years, they would be eligible for citizenship.

The eight senators in the bipartisan group that drafted the bill - four of whom are on the 18-member Judiciary Committee - have pledged to fend off changes that would derail the bill. They did so Thursday.

Several of the GOP-backed border control amendments were rejected with the help of two Republicans who worked on the bill, Sens. Lindsey Graham of South Carolina and Jeff Flake of Arizona.

Sen. Charles E. Grassley, R-Iowa, proposed an amendment that would have made immigrants wait for six months after the border was secure to apply for provisional legal status. Flake argued against it.

"They're in the shadows, and we've got to bring them out," Flake said. "We've got to know who's here."

The two senators similarly rejected an amendment from Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, that would have tripled the number of Border Patrol officers and quadrupled the amount spent on drones and other surveillance technology on the border.

Flake argued that the $30 billion to $40 billion in added costs would be untenable.

Although some exchanges were political and some pointed, senators were well aware they were in the midst of a moment in history.

Copyright 2014 Arizona Daily Star. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Follow the Arizona Daily Star

Deals, offers & events

View more...

More About Us

Chef Wendy Gauthier is the chef owner of Chef Chic.

Get weekly ads via e-mail