Baby sitter convicted in tub death of child

Woman, 28, guilty of negligent homicide in June 2012 drowning
2013-04-27T00:00:00Z 2013-04-30T11:54:06Z Baby sitter convicted in tub death of childVeronica M. Cruz Arizona Daily Star Arizona Daily Star
April 27, 2013 12:00 am  • 

A Tucson baby sitter who left a 10-month-old in a tub with running water and an open drain that became plugged with a plastic toy cup was found guilty of negligent homicide Friday.

Zada Davis, 28, placed Winter Breeze Azure in the tub to help soothe a diaper rash on June 12, 2012.

She then left the bathroom, cared for another child, browsed the Intenet, sorted clothes and didn't check on the baby for at least 40 minutes, Deputy Pima County Attorney Alan Goodwin told jurors Friday.

At one point she asked her 7-year-old daughter to check on the baby and the girl said she was "just fine," Davis testified.

When Davis did go check on the baby, water was overflowing from the tub and she was floating face down in it. Winter was taken to the hospital and taken off life support six days after the incident.  

Winter's death could have been prevented "oh so easily," Goodwin told jurors.

"All Ms. Davis had to do was check on her, all she had to do was not ignore her," Goodwin said.

Davis' actions showed "extreme indifference to human life," and encouraged jurors to consider a second-degree murder conviction, Goodwin said.

The incident was a "tragic accident" and Davis did not expect that what she did would be dangerous, Assistant Pima County Public Defender Steven Sonenberg contended.

Leaving the child in the tub with running water and an open drain was something she had done before without any issues, he said.

"Ms. Davis obviously did not know that this was going to happen, she did not consciously disregard a risk," Sonenberg said of the toy becoming stuck in the drain.

Witnesses described Davis as a caring baby sitter and her actions did not warrant a second-degree murder conviction, Sonenberg said.

"You know that she is a good person and you know that she wasn't extremely indifferent," Sonenberg told jurors.

Davis will be sentenced on June 17 by Judge Christopher Browning.

Contact reporter Veronica Cruz at or at 573-4224.

Copyright 2014 Arizona Daily Star. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


Follow the Arizona Daily Star

Deals, offers & events

View more...
Get weekly ads via e-mail