Judge rejects bid to find campaign contribution limits unconstitutional

2013-10-11T00:00:00Z 2013-10-25T12:06:10Z Judge rejects bid to find campaign contribution limits unconstitutionalBy Howard Fischer Capitol Media Services Arizona Daily Star
October 11, 2013 12:00 am  • 

PHOENIX — A judge on Thursday rejected a bid by an aide to Attorney General Tom Horne to have the limits on donations to candidates declared unconstitutional.

Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Sally Duncan sidestepped the legal issue of whether the caps — which the Secretary of State’s Office said Horne and Kathleen Winn violated — interfere with their First Amendment rights. Instead, she said Winn has no legal standing to challenge the laws at this point.

Duncan said Winn — and Horne — will have to wait until Yavapai County Attorney Sheila Polk decides whether to pursue charges against the pair.

The ruling disappointed Tim LaSota, Winn’s attorney. He was hoping for a ruling in his favor, a move that likely would have tossed the entire question of whether Winn and Horne might face campaign finance charges.

But the underlying question will not go away. And the ultimate answer will determine exactly how much money individuals can give and candidates can accept.

Even the U.S. Supreme Court has agreed to look at the question of whether current limits on contributions to federal candidates are unconstitutionally low.

At issue is $513,340 spent on a last-minute TV commercial for Horne’s 2010 campaign by Business Leaders for Arizona. The group was run by Winn, who had worked on Horne’s primary campaign but left to set up an independent committee for the general election.

Maricopa County Attorney Bill Montgomery, who got the initial report from the FBI, said that agency found evidence of coordination between the committee and Horne, which would violate multiple campaign-finance laws.

Montgomery turned the FBI findings over to Secretary of State Ken Bennett, as required by law.

The case was referred to  Polk. An aide said Thursday the issue was still under investigation.

LaSota had argued that Winn can’t be accused of breaking the law because the law itself is unconstitutional.

He said the Democrat Attorneys General Association, backing Democrat Felecia Rotellini, spent $1.5 million in the final days of the 2010 campaign attacking Horne.

By contrast, LaSota said, Horne was limited to taking no more than $840 from any individual, curbing his ability to respond. That led to the last-minute spending by Winn’s committee.

In his legal papers, LaSota did not address whether there was any coordination between Winn and Horne. Instead, he argued that the $840 limit “deprived Horne’s supporters of their ability to exercise their rights by helping him raise the resources necessary for effective campaign advocacy.”

“These limits were violative of Winn’s and Horne’s free-speech rights, rights to equal privileges and immunities, and equal protection of the law,” LaSota wrote.

Duncan, however, accepted arguments by Joe Kanefield, representing Bennett’s office, who pointed out that Polk has yet to decide whether to seek civil penalties against Winn or Horne, the remedy under campaign finance laws. Only if Polk proceeds, he argued, does the question of the campaign limits become relevant.

The U.S. Supreme Court is considering a challenge to a federal law that puts an absolute limit of $123,200 of how much any individual can donate during any two-year election cycle.

Attorneys for the government argued the limits were necessary to prevent corruption.

The court action also comes on the heels of a decision by Arizona lawmakers to sharply increase campaign finance limits here, also based on the same contention that the current caps are unconstitutionally low.

Copyright 2014 Arizona Daily Star. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Activate

Latest Election 2014 video

More

Election 2014: A look at the Star's endorsements

Arizona Daily Star reporter Becky Pallack talks with columnist Sarah Garrecht Gassen about the editorial pr…

Most Popular

Follow the Arizona Daily Star

Get weekly ads via e-mail