Landfill expansion will force some residents out

2014-03-10T00:00:00Z 2014-03-10T07:13:00Z Landfill expansion will force some residents outBy Yoohyun Jung For the Arizona Daily Star Arizona Daily Star

The city’s only remaining landfill is expanding, forcing out 14 households on properties adjacent to it.

A planned project to relocate the current Swan Road entrance to Los Reales Landfill three-quarters of a mile east, to Craycroft Road, in addition to building new facilities, wil=l extend the life of the landfill by about 60 years, officials say.

Rather than look for new locations for additional landfills, the city is looking to make Los Reales a long-term site, said Nancy Petersen, deputy director of the city’s Environmental Services.

Officials say the city will try to minimize harm and seek ways to maximize payment to those who are pushed out, but residents say they are concerned about what is going to happen next.

“I think a lot of people are afraid, not knowing, ‘Will they get enough money to get another place?’” said Doris White Wolff, who has been a neighbor of the landfill for more than 25 years. “Their whole lives are in limbo. We don’t know what’s going on.”

Currently, there is “no real buffer from the landfill to the residents,” Petersen said.

On an average day, about 500 trucks go into and out of the landfill, she said. Creating the new Craycroft Road entrance will ease the traffic queue and keep cars off main roads.

The upgrades would increase responsiveness to customers, safety for the public and financial efficiency for the city. The first phase, which will cost the city $7.5 million, will include a new entrance, access roads, administration and crew buildings, a scale-house pavilion, a household hazardous waste collection pavilion and a wheel-wash station.

Some residents complain the city is keeping them in the dark.

Wolff, who has lived in her mobile home near Los Reales since 1987, said she was startled to receive a letter from the city’s relocation contractor, Tierra Right of Way Services, Ltd., notifying her of relocation plans, since, she said, there had been no prior notices or neighborhood meetings.

A neighborhood meeting on Feb. 19 was held after the notices had already been sent out.

Carrie Martin experienced a similar shock.

“The day that I got that [letter], it was a terrible surprise,” she said.

Martin and her husband, Mike Hamlin, have been in the neighborhood since 1992.

Their manufactured home has been upgraded multiple times to accommodate more storage and Hamlin’s disability after a motorcycle accident.

“We don’t want to move,” Martin said.

The notification letter should have been sent out before a meeting, instead of after, said Hector Martinez, director of the city’s real-estate program. At the meeting, Martinez apologized to the residents.

“That was a misstep on Tierra,” he said. Tierra Right of Way Services was informed that the mayor and City Council approved the acquisition of those properties, and “misinterpreted that there was already some outreach to the residents.”

Myrlene Francis, project manager at Tierra, said the notification was issued to inform residents of the plan and not that relocation would actually be happening.

Wolff, Martin and Hamlin say all they want is to be treated fairly in the process and to have a home.

“We know we’re going to have to get out of here, but for myself, how am I going to survive?” Wolff said. “I do not want to walk into a mortgage. I paid this mortgage off. I’m not walking into a rental.”

Asked whether the properties’ proximity to the landfill would be used as a factor to determine market value, Martinez said that would be an appraiser’s decision.

“The appraiser will take all market factors into their conclusion of value,” he said. “I don’t want to speak to how the appraiser will come to a conclusion of value.”

He added that the city is not involved in deciding property values.

However, he said, the city will try to make the best possible offers. Residents will also be paid relocation benefits, which will be determined based on family size, age, special needs and economic situations.

“Hopefully, they understand that we are sensitive to what happened and sensitive to the whole issue of these types of acquisitions,” he said. “It does affect them. We are very cognizant of that. Although this is being done for the benefit of the community, we are sensitive to how disruptive it could be to them, and we try to minimize the harm based on the guidelines.”

According to documents provided by Martinez, appraisals are scheduled to begin in April.

Yoohyun Jung is a University of Arizona journalism student who is an apprentice at the Star. Contact her at starapprentice@azstarnet.com

Copyright 2014 Arizona Daily Star. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Latest Election 2014 video

More

Election 2014: Early ballot deadline and where to vote

Learn how to turn in your early election ballot or find your polling place with the help of Star reporters …

Follow the Arizona Daily Star

Deals, offers & events

View more...
Get weekly ads via e-mail