Will deal prevent Iran from going nuclear?

Deal may help, but entire area must be de-nuked — including Israel

2013-12-02T00:00:00Z Deal may help, but entire area must be de-nuked — including IsraelBy John B. Quigley(EDITORS: The writer is addressing the question, “Will interim deal prevent Iran from getting nuclear weapons?”)  Arizona Daily Star

The interim deal struck with Iran by the “5 plus 1” powers shows promise for achieving the end that Iran will not obtain a nuclear weapon.

Whether it is the deal that will be responsible for that end depends, of course, on whether Iran was building nuclear weapons at all. If Iran does not develop nuclear weapons, we may never know whether it was the deal that brought that about.

Iran claims to the “5 plus 1” powers — the five permanent members of the U.N. Security Council plus Germany — that its nuclear program is for peaceful purposes. That receives some confirmation from the deal, because Iran is making a substantial commitment in return for only a modest reduction in sanctions. Iran’s willingness to give up so much for so little may mean that it was not working toward nuclear weapons in the first place.

But on the assumption that Iran is working toward nuclear arms, the deal puts a crimp in any such efforts. Iran says it will stop high-level enrichment of uranium and neutralize its stockpile of uranium that it has enriched to a high level. It will install no new centrifuges, these being necessary to enrich uranium.

The West has been suspicious of Iran’s activities at a reactor in the town of Arak. Iran now commits to stop any production of nuclear fuel at that facility. It will provide design information on the Arak reactor — information previously not available.

Importantly, Iran will allow inspections by the International Atomic Energy Agency much more broadly than before. Thus, the “5 plus 1” are not relying on Iran’s word alone.

Finally, the deal is short-term only — a mere six months. The concept is to keep Iran from activity that might bring it closer to weaponry while efforts are made for a permanent deal. The International Atomic Energy Agency reported several weeks ago that Iran was already slowing production that held weapons potential.

If Iran violates the deal, the promised reductions in sanctions could disappear. Sanctions could be reinstated or increased.

Iran is getting only a modest reduction in the sanctions that have been crippling its economy. So its economy will continue to be crippled during the six-month period. For Iran, the deal is no free ride. One can never ensure that a state bent on nuclear weapons will never develop them. So no matter how much Iran dismantles now, it could pick up again.

States sometimes see a need for nuclear weapons to counter adversaries who have them. In the Middle East, the only state with nuclear weapons is Israel.



Israel has never allowed outside inspections, it has refused to sign the nuclear non-proliferation treaty, and it refuses even to acknowledge the nuclear weapons it is known to possess.

The “5 plus 1” countries are silent on Israel’s nuclear weapons. Pressuring Iran while giving Israel only a wink and a nod lends a political cast to the efforts of the “5 plus 1.” They could achieve the moral high ground — and reduce the risk of Iran going nuclear — if they committed to seeking elimination of nuclear weapons in the entire Middle East.

John B. Quigley is a professor of law at Ohio State University.

Copyright 2014 Arizona Daily Star. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Activate

Latest Fitz Report video

More

Fitz studio: How to draw the President

In this video tutorial, Star cartoonist and columnist David Fitzsimmons teaches you how to draw the Preside…

Latest Newsmakers video

More

Dr. Peter Rhee on mental health

Dr. Peter Rhee discusses mental health and other issues surrounding gun violence.

Featured businesses

View more...

Deals, offers & events

View more...

Clean your hand woven rugs

3630 E Fort Lowell Rd Tucson, AZ 85716 520-319-8280 www.karimi…