Letters to the editor

2013-12-06T00:00:00Z Letters to the editor Arizona Daily Star
December 06, 2013 12:00 am

Readers sound off on the death of bighorn sheep and mountain lions in the Catalina Mountains.

Mountain lions dying for natural behavior

As expected, Game and Fish has decided to murder two native mountain lions because they did what lions naturally do, killed and ate two bighorn sheep.

The original herd died out 20 years ago because their habitat was slowly being encroached upon by man. Hikers, dogs and development ate away at the habitat and the sheep died out.

If anything, today there is more encroachment, development and hiking. The new herd simply cannot and will not survive.

So what does Game and Fish do? Go on a killing spree to eradicate mountain lions.

How is this even legal?

When will they cut their losses and stop this terrible reintroduction?

Leave the sheep where they thrive near Yuma, and stop finding excuses for murdering lions for acting like lions.

No matter how many sheep they transport to the Catalinas it is just a matter of time before they too are extinct.

This is a travesty and a senseless loss of both sheep and lions. How utterly sad.

Raymond J. Santoro

Postal worker, Tucson

Forcibly moving herd

of sheep was a mistake

The actions of the Arizona Game and Fish Department are deplorable.

The transplanting of the bighorn herd to the Catalinas was an ill-conceived idea at best. The fact that the original herd died out is reason alone to question this move.

Killing two mountain lions for doing what they are born to do is truly disgusting.

Bighorn sheep survive primarily by becoming agile, sure-footed creatures that adopt a cliff-type habitat that is essentially inaccessible by predators.

If such a habitat is not available to them, then they have been put in the wrong place.

If Game and Fish wants to raise the sheep like domestic livestock, protecting them from all predators, they should become ranchers, not wildlife managers.

The department spokesman is quoted as saying these killings were done by the book.

Apparently, “the book” is not based on common sense.

The biggest challenge to the survival of our wildlife is Arizona Game and Fish.

Paul Joy

Retired, Sierra Vista

Shame, shame, shame

on AZ Game and Fish

Now let me get this straight. The Arizona Game and Fish Department transplants, at taxpayers’ expense, 31 bighorn sheep from their natural habitat in Yuma to the Catalina Mountains, the natural habitat of mountain lions.

Within weeks, two bighorns are found dead and for that reason two mountain lions are killed by Game and Fish.

What a surprise!

What did they expect from this experiment?

That the lions would not stalk the sheep for food?

It appears the department’s stupidity is only surpassed by their desire to destroy God’s creatures.

This is just another attempt by these people to override the natural order of nature by taking things into their own hands.

My heart bleeds for both of these beautiful species that are being needlessly led to the slaughter.

Shame, shame, shame!

Sally Alves

Retired business owner, Rio Rico

Why can’t we leave

well enough alone?

The mountain lions are thinking, “Thanks for the snacks!” Little do they realize their “patoot” is grass.

Well-meaning groups may want to restore and manipulate nature to what they deem is the ideal by trying to bring back what once was.

However, their actions do not always bring the desired results.

Mountain lions are only doing what comes naturally and should not be punished for it.

Why does one species have to suffer at the expense of another? Why, oh why, can’t we ever leave well enough alone?

Paula Sherrick

Retired, Tucson

ED Letter Hed goes here two lines

I am horrified that the only alternative to the mountain lions killing the newly released bighorn sheep is to kill them. Surely this can’t be a surprise to the Arizona Game and Fish Department.

I am thrilled that the bighorns have been reintroduced to the Catalina Mountains, but I should think the mountain lions who have committed this “crime” could be relocated rather than killed. Shame on Game and Fish for not having a better conservation plan.

Dee Schiavelli

Marketing consultant, Tucson

Copyright 2014 Arizona Daily Star. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Latest Fitz Report video


Fitz studio: How to draw the President

In this video tutorial, Star cartoonist and columnist David Fitzsimmons teaches you how to draw the Preside…

Latest Newsmakers video


Sarah interviews Dr. Peter Rhee, part 2 of 3

Dr. Peter Rhee discusses mental health and other issues surrounding gun violence.

Featured businesses

View more...

Deals, offers & events

View more...