Hospital charges in US vary wildly

Database reveals huge differences in billing that 'don't make sense'
2013-05-09T00:00:00Z 2013-05-09T16:54:25Z Hospital charges in US vary wildlyThe Associated Press The Associated Press
May 09, 2013 12:00 am  • 

WASHINGTON - For the first time, the government is publicly revealing how much hospitals charge, and the differences are astounding: Some bill tens of thousands of dollars more than others for the same treatment, even within the same city.

Why does a joint replacement cost 40 times as much at one hospital as at another across the country? It's a mystery, federal health officials say.

"It doesn't make sense," Jonathan Blum, Medicare deputy administrator, said Wednesday. The higher charges don't reflect better care, he said.

And the amounts are too huge to be explained by obvious differences among hospitals, such as a more expensive regional economy, older or sicker patients, or the extra costs of running a teaching hospital, he said.

The average charges for joint replacement range from about $5,300 at an Ada, Okla., hospital to $223,000 in Monterey Park, Calif., the Department of Health and Human Services said. That doesn't include doctors' fees.

Hospitals within the same city also vary greatly. At Beth Israel Medical Center in New York, the average charge to treat a blood clot in a lung is $51,580. Down the street at NYU Hospitals Center, the charge for the same care would be $29,869.

At the Mayo Clinic in Minnesota, the list price is $16,861.

The list price isn't necessarily what you pay.

Medicare pays hospitals on its own fee schedule that isn't based on the listed charges, Blum said. And insurance companies routinely negotiate discount rates with the hospitals.

But patients who are uninsured can be billed the full amount. And some with private insurance may find their share of the bill is inflated as a result of a hospital's higher charges, officials said.

Blum said the Obama administration hopes that releasing the information, at www.cms.gov online, will help lead to answers to the riddle of hospital pricing - and pressure some hospitals to lower their charges.

The database also will help consumers shop around, he said.

The variations shouldn't be a surprise, since hospitals might violate antitrust regulations if they shared "proposed or negotiated rates" with each other, said Rich Umbdenstock, president of the American Hospital Association. Forty states do require or encourage hospitals to make some payment information publicly available, he said.

"The complex and bewildering interplay among 'charges,' 'rates,' 'bills' and 'payments' across dozens of payers, public and private, does not serve any stakeholder well, including hospitals," Umbdenstock said.

Consumer advocates said making the charges public is significant, even if most patients don't pay those rates.

"I think the point is to shame hospitals," said Chapin White of the nonprofit Center for Studying Health System Change.

Dr. David Goodman, co-author of the Dartmouth Atlas of Health Care, said, "It does show how crazy the system really is, and it needs some reform."

Goodman argues that hospitals should be required to go further and post the charges that patients actually pay out-of-pocket, depending on what medical coverage they have. The Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy has long found wide geographic variation in Medicare payments for the similarly ill, yet people who receive more expensive care don't necessarily receive better care. Sometimes hospitals add tests or treatments they don't really need.

A hospital's charges are akin to a car dealership's "list price." Hospitals say they frequently give discounts to the uninsured - $41 billion in financial aid in 2011.

But some people pay full price, or try to afford it, because they don't know they can seek a discount, White said.

And even for those who do bargain, the listed charge "is the opening bid in the hospital's attempt to get as much money as possible out of you," he said.

At Suburban Hospital in Bethesda, Md. - serving an affluent community at the gates of the National Institutes of Health - the average charge for simple pneumonia was $5,284. Compare that to $79,365 at Hahnemann University Hospital in Philadelphia.

The database lists the average charges for the 100 most common Medicare inpatient services at more than 3,000 hospitals. The prices, from 2011, represent about 60 percent of Medicare inpatient cases.

"Hospitals that charge two or three times the going rate will rightfully face scrutiny," Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius told reporters.

And consumers will get insight into a mystifying system that too often leaves them with little way of knowing what a hospital will charge or what their insurance companies are paying for treatments, Sebelius said.

hospital charges in Tucson

Among hospitals serving Medicare patients, the federal goverment has documented a wide disparity in charges for many commonly performed inpatient procedures. The following chart includes charges for several of the most common procedures. Find the complete list at www.hhs.gov

Tucson Carondelet Carondelet The University Northwest Oro Medical St. Mary's St. Joseph's of Arizona Medical Valley National Procedure Center Hospital Hospital Medical Center Center Hospital Average

Blood clot in lung $21,234.32 $23,534.40 $27,816.18 $18,650.56 $30,063.87 $30,215.73 $26,738.11

Bronchitis/asthma $24,561.85 $19,779.81 $33,713.60 - $23,198.15 - $23,201.77

Chest pain $17,284.69 $20,766.43 $19,779.75 $17,778.50 $18,377.95 - $16,948.33

Heart attack $34,066.57 $56,383.36 $46,076.04 $58,650.74 $43,495.55 - $45,924.29

Heart failure $27,629.31 $34,853.07 $35,876.18 $49,047.76 $35,353.13 $28,468.50 $35,901.91

Hip/pelvis fracture $12,773.13 - $14,988.27 $20,616.72 $14,827.94 - $17,482.14

Kidney failure $34,480.24 $33,515.00 $37,531.15 $31,791.50 $58,299.36 $40,725.27 $39,926.34

Major joint replacement $82,478.12 $63,960.73 $70,780.18 - $79,971.96 - $81,704.23

Pacemaker implant $45,610.21 - $66,510.68 - $71,487.03 $71,168.25 $67,865.72

Pneumonia $16,629.32 $18,232.50 $22,053.00 $14,809.96 $20,654.40 $18,378.28 $17,886.49

Diabetes - $17,079.20 $19,324.67 $25,710.12 $25,840.28 - $21,596.54

The cost of kidney failure

A federal government report shows hospital charges for various inpatient procedures differ widely - and inexplicably. Find more examples on Page A4

Tucson Medical Center $34,480.24

Carondelet St. Mary's $33,515.00

Carondelet St. Joseph's $37,531.15

The University of Arizona Medical Center $31,791.50

Northwest Medical Center $58,299.36

Oro Valley Hospital $40,725.27

National average $39,926.34

Copyright 2014 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Activate

Follow the Arizona Daily Star

Featured businesses

View more...

Deals, offers & events

View more...

$15.99 Oil Change Special!

K&D Quality Auto is offering $15.99 conventional 10w30 oi…