Republicans file new challenge to congressional district lines

2013-09-24T00:00:00Z Republicans file new challenge to congressional district linesBy Howard Fischer Capitol Media Services Arizona Daily Star
September 24, 2013 12:00 am  • 

PHOENIX — Bested 5-4 in last year’s congressional races, Republican legislative leaders want a federal court to immediately give them the power to draw the lines for 2014.

In new court filings Friday, attorneys for lawmakers point out the U.S. Constitution gives the Legislature the authority to decide the “times, places and manner’’ of congressional elections. They contend that overrides the 2000 decision by voters to give that power, along with drawing legislative boundaries, to the five-member Independent Redistricting Commission.

With candidates now starting to explore congressional races — including current state House Speaker Andy Tobin — the lawyers want a three-judge panel to bar use of the lines the commission adopted for the 2012 election, when Democrats took five of the state’s nine congressional seats.

Legislators want the portion of the 2000 initiative dealing with congressional races overturned. And that would return Arizona to the way it was before, with lawmakers from the majority party deciding where to draw the lines.

Tobin said Monday that he envisions a special legislative session this fall to re-craft the districts, if the court sides with challengers.

He said the lawsuit has nothing to do with the outcome of the 2012 races. Tobin said he always has opposed the idea of the nonelected commission crafting boundaries, but was not in the Legislature in 2002 or in a position to contest what happened then.

But Tobin conceded there was little interest by Republicans in challenging the process at that time because the lines drawn a decade ago were probably more favorable to the GOP. The work of the latest commission — new members are named every decade — was decidedly different.

“The truth is, this Independent Redistricting Commission was stolen,’’ he said.

Tobin also said his interest is unrelated to the fact he does not live in the congressional district where he wants to run — the one currently represented by Democrat Ann Kirkpatrick.

Federal law does not require candidates to live in their own districts, though not being a resident can be a political disadvantage. But the House speaker, who would have some sway in drawing new lines if that power were returned to the Legislature, said he objected to the commission’s work in 2011, long before he was weighing federal office.

Political issues aside, commission attorney Joe Kanefield said the challenge will fail.

He acknowledged the federal constitutional language. But he said that’s missing the point.

“The (U.S.) Supreme Court has made clear that the term refers to the entire lawmaking process of the state, and not just the state’s legislative body,’’ he wrote in his own legal filings. And he said the voters, as the ultimate source of authority in Arizona, are free to delegate the legislative duties of redistricting to the commission.

Hanging in the balance is the political makeup of the state’s congressional delegation.

The lines drawn by the Republican-controlled Legislature up through the 2000 election gave Democrats just one of the six seats the state had at that time.

In 2002, the first election after voters approved Proposition 106, creating the commission, Republicans took six of the eight seats. But the balance fluctuated during the decade, with two years when Democrats had five of the eight seats, though it bounced back to 5-3 Republican in the 2010 race.



Copyright 2014 Arizona Daily Star. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Activate

Follow the Arizona Daily Star

Featured businesses

View more...

Deals, offers & events

View more...

½ Price bottle of wine!

Come in Monday and Tuesday and pay ½ price on a bottle of wine