World Series Controversy

Umps say Game 3 call was correct

2013-10-28T00:00:00Z Umps say Game 3 call was correctThe Associated Press The Associated Press
October 28, 2013 12:00 am  • 

ST. LOUIS — By Sunday morning, most everyone had become an expert on the obstruction rule.

“How can u make a call like that in the World Series,” rapper Lil Wayne tweeted.

“Worst ending to a World Series game ever!” PGA golfer Hunter Mahan posted.

“Obstruction of justice,” Arizona Cardinals kicker Jay Feely wrote.

No matter that the Official Baseball Rules have a slightly different take on what happened between the Cardinals and Red Sox in Game 3 at Busch Stadium.

But anytime someone scores the winning run with two outs in the bottom of the ninth inning without even touching home plate — called safe on an extremely rare ruling by an umpire — it’s bound to cause a little ruckus.

On this point, all sides seemed to agree: Allen Craig’s wild trip over Boston third baseman Will Middlebrooks likely made for the most crazy, chaotic October finish of all-time.

And it gave St. Louis a 5-4 win Saturday night.

“As a baseball fan, you hate to see a game end like that,” pitcher Adam Wainwright said Sunday before Game 4. “Obviously I’m on the Cardinals, so I’m fortunate the rule is the way it is. And you hate to say it, but he impeded the process of running home.”

“But I totally understand why Red Sox players would be upset about that. That is just a horrible way to lose a baseball game, no question about it,” he said.

For more than a century, the World Series has delivered dramatic endings — Kirk Gibson’s homer, Carlton Fisk’s shot, David Freese’s drive on this very same field in 2011.

There have been plenty of kooky plays — Reggie Jackson turning his hip to get hit by a throw, Roger Clemens throwing part of a broken bat toward Mike Piazza, an out in the 1970 Series when the catcher missed the runner and the runner missed the plate.

But no one had seen anything quite like this.

“Never,” umpire crew chief John Hirschbeck said.

“Never,” third base umpire Jim Joyce said after making the call.

Said Craig: “I didn’t know if I was out or safe or not.”

Craig was awarded home after getting tangled with Middlebrooks. A wild throw set off the sequence, and Middlebrooks was sprawled in the baseline and kicked up his legs as Craig tripped over him.

Running on a banged-up foot, Craig headed home and the throw by left fielder Daniel Nava beat him. Catcher Jarrod Saltalamacchia made the tag in plenty of time and Craig never reached the plate. But umpire Dana DeMuth signaled safe, having seen Joyce’s call at third base.

Both teams immediately rushed to the plate. Middlebrooks threw down his glove and joined the Boston argument. The Cardinals came out to celebrate.

The fans took awhile to react, unsure of what they’d just witnessed.

“I think maybe 75 percent of the guys didn’t know what happened,” Cardinals star Carlos Beltran said.

“I wasn’t sure why he was called safe,” Middlebrooks said.

Middlebrooks said any contact was accidental. Doesn’t matter, though. The play is covered by Rule 2.00 and Rule 7.06, and makes it clear that obstruction is called anytime a runner is impeded.

“It does not have to be intent. There does not have to be intent. OK?” Hirschbeck said.

Not OK, Boston pitcher Jake Peavy said.

“It’s a joke,” Peavy groused.

Saltalamacchia was more forgiving.

“At the end of the day, if it was obstruction, you’ve got to call it. It’s part of the game,” he said.

Copyright 2014 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Activate

Latest Video

More videos

State House LD2 candidate: Chris Ackerley

Chris Ackerley discusses voter concerns, including education.



Follow the Arizona Daily Star

Featured businesses

View more...

Deals, offers & events

View more...