Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Coalition tells court several new Arizona laws cannot be enforced
top story

Coalition tells court several new Arizona laws cannot be enforced

  • Updated

Sophia Glover, 7, raises her hand during Summer school class at Johnson Primary School in June.

PHOENIX — A coalition of school board members, educators, child welfare advocates and others is asking a judge to void a host of changes in state law approved in the waning days of the legislative session.

Attorney Roopali Desai is not alleging that any of these new laws, individually, is illegal. They range from whether schools and even universities can impose mask mandates and changes to election laws to banning the teaching of what legislators and Gov. Doug Ducey have incorrectly labeled “critical race theory.’’

The legal problem, she said, is that these were combined with other unrelated provisions into what lawmakers call “budget reconciliation bills,’’ essentially a grab-bag of issues.

That, said Desai, violates constitutional provisions that clearly state each piece of legislation “shall embrace but one subject and matters properly connected therewith.’’ And that same provision requires each element to be laid out in the title.

What that means, she is telling Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Katherine Cooper, is that each of the challenged provisions was illegally enacted — and cannot be enforced.

If Desai wins the case, the implications go beyond nullifying the challenged provisions and, most immediately, ending the legal risk that now exists for schools, colleges and universities who are requiring staff and students to wear masks while on campus. It also would force a major change in the long-standing practice of lawmakers doing what she called “horse-trading,’’ piling unrelated issued — many which had previously failed on their own — into a single package designed to corral the necessary votes.

Senate President Karen Fann, R-Prescott, said she could not comment until she reviews the lawsuit with attorneys. But C.J. Karamargin, press aide to Gov. Doug Ducey, said he is “confident the legislation we signed is constitutional.’’

All this comes as the Department of Health Services, whose director Dr. Cara Christ has said she backs the decision by the governor and lawmakers to bar mandated mask use in schools, reported more than 3,000 new cases of COVID19, a level that hasn’t been seen in six months.

At the same time, hospitals reported 1,590 in-patient beds — 18% of capacity — occupied by COVID-19 patients. And 22% of intensive-care beds were being used by COVID-19 patients.

The new lawsuit comes as the attorney for a Phoenix Union High School teacher asked Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Randall Warner on Friday to void a mask mandate enacted by the district’s governing board.

Alexander Kolodin said that act specifically runs afoul of a provision in one of those budget reconciliation bills now being challenged by Desai barring schools from imposing mask mandates. And he argued the district is powerless to ignore the statute.

But Mary O’Grady asked Warner to toss the lawsuit, saying that statutes, including the one Kolodin is using, are not effective until the 91st day after the end of the session. And this year, that is Sept. 29.

Kolodin, however, contends these are budget bills that take effect immediately.

But that whole argument of effective dates becomes moot if Desai wins her own lawsuit and the court voids not just the anti-mask language but everything else she argues was enacted unconstitutionally.

All that goes to the requirement limiting each measure to a single subject and having the title properly reflect what is in the bill.

It starts with HB 2898 which has the language banning not just school districts but also counties, cities and towns from requiring the use of face coverings or proof of vaccination against COVID-19 to participate in in-person instruction.

What’s also in the 231-page bill is a provision prohibiting teaching curriculum “that presents any form of blame or judgment on the basis of race, ethnicity or sex.’’ That includes concepts like saying a student “should feel discomfort, guilt, anguish, or any other form of psychological distress because of the individual’s race, ethnicity or sex’’ and even authorizes the state Board of Education to suspend or revoke an offending teacher’s certificate.

Only thing is, Desai said, HB 2898 is titled “appropriating monies, relating to kindergarten through grade twelve budget reconciliation.’’ The reality, she said, is the bill includes “substantive policies that have nothing to do with the budget.’’

“It’s bad enough that the titles don’t describe what’s actually happening in these bills,’’ Desai told Capitol Media Services. “But the legislature went out of its way to mislead people about what’s in the bills.’’

For example, SB 1824, dubbed as “appropriating monies; relating to health budget reconciliation,’’ says students cannot be required to be immunized to attend school suing any vaccination that has only been given “emergency use authorization’’ by the Food and Drug Administration. That, for the moment, is the status of all COVID vaccines.

And another section bars local governments from establishing a “vaccine passport’’ or requiring proof of vaccination to enter a business.

Then there’s SB 1819 that, according to its title, deals with “budget procedures.’’ But that bill includes “fraud countermeasures’’ for paper ballots and strips power from Secretary of State Katie Hobbs to defend election law challenges. What’s also in that bill is setting up a special committee to review the findings of the audit of the 2020 election, changes to the governor’s emergency powers, investigating the practices of social medial platforms and even language about condominiums.

“None of these subjects have any logical connection to each other,’’ Desai said.

On Twitter: @azcapmedia

Subscribe to stay connected to Tucson. A subscription helps you access more of the local stories that keep you connected to the community.

Get local news delivered to your inbox!

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News