Skip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
Vigilance fighting COVID-19 in Arizona is crucial, but not necessarily widespread testing, health officials say
top story

Vigilance fighting COVID-19 in Arizona is crucial, but not necessarily widespread testing, health officials say

From the Tucson-area coronavirus coverage from January to March: Nearly 1,300 cases in Arizona, stay-at-home order series

As the number of known coronavirus cases continues to increase throughout the state and the nation, Arizona health department officials say widespread testing is not critical for assessing the crisis.

It’s information Jessica Rigler, assistant director of public health preparedness for the Arizona Department of Health Services, hopes will ease anxiety about the lack of available testing due to supply shortages and other factors.

As of Friday afternoon, there were 63 known cases of coronavirus in Arizona, including eight in Pima County.

Widespread testing is not necessarily that important, she said, and the role of so-called drive-thru or drive-up testing for COVID-19 should be reserved mostly for health-care workers who are monitoring their health and for people who work with vulnerable populations.

Dr. Cara Christ, the director of the state Department of Health Services, said Friday that Arizonans should pretty much forget about getting testing to determine if they have the virus.

“We continue to face a national shortage of test collection supplies and lab reagents,” Christ said. “There are not enough tests at this time for everyone who wants to be tested.”

But she said that, for those who do not have extreme symptoms like difficulty breathing, knowing whether they have COVID-19 or something else won’t really help them.

“It’s important to be clear: There is no specific treatment for this disease,” Christ said. “And the result of a COVID-19 test will not change your clinical treatment while you are sick.”

Limits on testing

There are now drive-up sites outside Banner-UMC Tucson and Banner-UMC South, but they are not for people to get random testing.

The medical centers have implemented emergency department external triage outside of these hospitals that is for normal emergency department screening, not specifically COVID-19 testing, said spokeswoman Rebecca Ruiz McGill.

In other words, if a person is having any symptoms that require an emergency-room visit, they will be screened outside in their car. This is being done to protect patients and health-care workers inside the hospital.

People who suspect they have COVID-19 should call their doctor, or if they don’t have a regular doctor, seek out emergency care. The symptoms to watch for include ongoing dizziness, chest pain and breathing trouble.

Otherwise, Rigler said people who are sick with more minor symptoms should stay home and isolate until the sickness resolves. They do not need to get tested, she said. This needs to happen in coordination with communities practicing social isolation and other ways to prevent transmission, such as regular hand-washing.

Rigler said many people have thought widespread testing is needed in order to see how much the virus is spreading, but there are other factors utilized without the widespread testing.

These include daily assessments of hospital admissions, what’s being seen in emergency rooms, daily bed and ICU capacity in each hospital and reports of influenza-like illnesses.

“While Arizonans don’t need to panic, they do need to be concerned about the spreading of this disease,” Rigler said. “The absence of testing does not mean an absence of data. All of the other indicators help us understand what’s going on in the state.”

In Pima County, Banner is currently the only one that offers drive-thru testing for COVID-19, but the criteria for testing is limited, and an appointment is required before anyone can be screened.

Lack of supplies

Arizona is working on a federal resource request for more ventilators and is also assessing staffing capacity across the state to make sure there are enough qualified professionals to operate the equipment, although Rigler could not say when that request will be ready.

According to Rigler, the shortage of medical supplies is just one of the reasons why they are discouraging widespread testing of people who aren’t experiencing serious symptoms.

They also need to save the protective gear used by medical staff during testing. That same protective gear is in short supply and needs to be saved for patients who will need emergency care and intensive care.

“We know we will probably not receive everything we need from the federal government and the supply chain is not as robust as it could be,” she said. “That’s why we need to work together.”

On top of the shortage of testing kits, medical professionals also don’t have the supplies needed to collect samples, including nasal swabs. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the swabs have to be long and skinny enough to get to the nasopharynx — the upper part of the throat, behind the nose — and must be made of synthetic fiber.

“What we’re really focused on is making those resources more available in Pima County,” said Aaron Pacheco, community relations program manager at the Pima County Health Department. “The main need that we’ve identified at this point is not necessarily testing capability — these labs are capable of doing them — it’s really the supplies to do and collect the samples.”

As more screening and testing is done, there is also an increased chance that the state will see a backlog of testing kits, which is why more labs are being set up to do the testing.

In Flagstaff, the Translational Genomics Research Institute is now testing for the coronavirus, which will help boost the state’s testing efforts.

The likelihood of laboratories getting more backup as testing increases is a very real concern, Rigler said, and that’s why the state is validating more labs to do testing right now. Overall, she said, Arizona will be keeping the state lab free for priority specimens from people who are the most vulnerable to severe complications of the disease.

Howard Fischer of Capitol Media Services contributed to this story. Contact reporter Jasmine Demers at

Subscribe to stay connected to Tucson. A subscription helps you access more of the local stories that keep you connected to the community.

Concerned about COVID-19?

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.


Jasmine joined the Star in 2019. With a master’s degree in journalism, Jasmine served in a variety of leadership roles, including The Daily Wildcat's editor-in-chief. She was also named Outstanding Newsperson of the Year by the UA School of Journalism.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News