Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Local Opinion: Biden's plan 'lifting all boats,' but may raise expectations too high

Local Opinion: Biden's plan 'lifting all boats,' but may raise expectations too high

In a 1963 speech, President John F. Kennedy stated, “No American is ever made better off by pulling a fellow American down, and every American is made better off whenever any one of us is made better off. A rising tide raises all boats.”

Some interpreted this to mean that the rich should not be taxed to help those who are not rich. Others see this quote justifying providing social services for the low and middle class, with the reasoning that as their economic situation improves, so does the nation as a whole.

President Biden’s Build Back Better Act, designed to increase taxes for the super-rich while providing economic benefits to low-and middle-class families all in one fell swoop, is bound to rise the tide so high it causes damaging flooding. Most disturbing is that it sets up expectations with promises that simply cannot be fulfilled for decades to come.

Take the example of the promise of universal preschool for 3- and 4-year-olds. There is not now, nor is there likely to be in the near future, the personnel and facilities to make this a reality, as desirable as it is. There are scholarships available through the American Recovery Act for more families to enroll their young children right now that are going unused in communities large and small because there simply are not openings in existing preschools for additional enrollment.

That portion of the funding should first be dedicated to providing the resources needed to expand access, including educating for free potential preschool teachers and aides, building facilities in which to house preschools, providing all that is needed to support high-quality services, and increasing salaries to make this an attractive vocation. Fund the horse before the cart.

There is one aspect of Biden’s Build Back Better Act, however, that indeed is lifting all boats right now, and if continued, will do so for years to come. That is the proposal to continue the increased child tax credit. This full benefit for couples earning less than $150,000 a year and single parents $75,000 has already risen at least 40 percent of families out of poverty, according to numerous research institutions.

The child tax credit itself is not new. Before the increase, the deduction of $2,000 for each eligible child was calculated when income taxes were filed. With the added federal funding, the credit increased to $3,000 for those that qualify for children between 6 and 17 years old and to $3,600 for children under 6 years old. Perhaps what made these increases most immediately beneficial is that families did not have to wait until they filed their 2022 taxes to receive funding.

From July through December this year, families were provided a payment each month. For a family with one parent working as a law enforcement officer and the other as a teacher, their adjusted yearly income would be approximately $110,000 based on the average salaries in Arizona for those positions. If the couple had two children over 6 and one under, they would be receiving a payment of $800 a month. When they do file taxes, they can claim the other 50 percent of the child tax credit to offset their owed taxes or even get a refund if their owed taxes are less than that. But that increase and monthly check ends in December.

Even in this family of two working parents, the tide is risen all around them, given the soaring costs of just about everything. Imagine what the payments are doing for the truly poor in terms of providing food, clothing, housing, and other necessities. This benefits the providers of these goods and landlords as it indeed trickles down even to those without children, not just in theory but also in reality. And more boats do indeed float. Let’s keep it that way for a truly better America.

Scott is an educator and long-term resident of Nogales, Arizona.

Subscribe to stay connected to Tucson. A subscription helps you access more of the local stories that keep you connected to the community.

Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

OPINION: "It is clear that state laws must be changed. Whether it is thrill-seeking or macho bravado, there is no place for loaded firearms outside the home. Home is where you should definitely stand your ground, because that is, by definition, ‘your ground.’ Legislators must pass laws that protect the public from thrill-seekers and bullies," writes Marana resident and retired research psychologist Tony Maitland. 

OPINION: "The challenges of college affordability and workforce development are linked, yet too complex for either the government or business community to solve alone. A public-private solution is what’s needed. That’s why we gathered on Thursday at the University of Arizona with some of the state’s smartest minds in business and education," write Gov. Doug Ducey and Wesley D. Kremer, president of Raytheon Missiles and Defense.

  • Updated

OPINION: "As we move boldly, yet with humility, into our next 100 years, we’re guided by our successes over the last century. We do so with the understanding that today’s needs still require the same spirit of collaboration, the duty for which I believe we’ve been called, and the confidence that we can continue to bring systemic positive change to our community by uniting people, ideas, and resources," writes Tony Penn, president of United Way of Tucson and Southern Arizona.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News