Skip to main contentSkip to main content
Register for more free articles.
Log in Sign up
Back to homepage
Subscriber Login
Keep reading with a digital access subscription.
Subscribe now
You have permission to edit this collection.
Edit
Arizona Daily Star
76°
  • Sign in
  • Subscribe Now
  • Manage account
  • Logout
    • Manage account
    • e-Newspaper
    • Logout
  • News
    • Sign up for newsletters
    • Local
    • Arizona
    • Business
    • Crime
    • Nation & World
    • Markets & Stocks
    • SaddleBrooke
    • Politics
    • Archives
    • News Tip
  • Arizona Daily Star
    • E-edition
    • E-edition-Tutorial
    • Archives
    • Special Sections
    • Merchandise
    • Circulars
    • Readers' Choice Awards
    • Buyer's Edge
  • Obituaries
    • Share Your Story
    • Recent Obituaries
    • Find an Obituary
  • Opinion
    • Submit a Letter
    • Submit guest opinion
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Opinion & Editorials
    • National Columnists
  • Sports
    • Arizona Wildcats
    • Greg Hansen
    • High Schools
    • Roadrunners
    • Scores
  • Lifestyles
    • Events Calendar
    • Arts & Theatre
    • Food & Cooking
    • Movies & TV
    • Movie Listings
    • Music
    • Comics
    • Games
    • Columns
    • Play
    • Home & Gardening
    • Health
    • Get Healthy
    • Parenting
    • Fashion
    • People
    • Pets
    • Travel
    • Faith
    • Retro Tucson
    • History
    • Travel
    • Outdoors & Rec
    • Community Pages
  • Brand Ave. Studios
  • Join the community
    • News tip
    • Share video
  • Buy & Sell
    • Place an Ad
    • Shop Local
    • Jobs
    • Homes
    • Marketplace
    • I Love A Deal
  • Shopping
  • Customer Service
    • Manage My Account
    • Newsletter Sign-Up
    • Subscribe
    • Contact us
  • Mobile Apps
  • Weather: Live Radar
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Bluesky
  • YouTube
  • Pinterest
  • Instagram
© 2026 Lee Enterprises
Terms of Service | Privacy Policy
Arizona Daily Star
News+
Read Today's E-edition
Arizona Daily Star
News+
  • Log In
  • $1 for 3 months
    Subscribe Now
    • Manage account
    • e-Newspaper
    • Logout
  • E-edition
  • News
  • Obituaries
  • Opinion
  • Wildcats
  • Lifestyles
  • Newsletters
  • Comics & Puzzles
  • Readers' Choice Awards
  • Jobs
  • 76° Sunny
Share This
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Bluesky
  • WhatsApp
  • SMS
  • Email

CD 1 candidates

  • Aug 6, 2012
  • Aug 6, 2012 Updated Aug 7, 2012
Prefer us on Google

The race to replace U.S. Rep. Paul Gosar in the upcoming Congressional District 1 election has yielded three Republican candidates, including one familiar to Southern Arizonans. Two Democratic candidates are running for the seat, as well.

Creating jobs a key factor for 2 in CD1 Dem primary

Two Democratic candidates are running for this year's Congressional District 1 seat.

One, Flagstaff attorney Wenona Benally Baldenegro, hopes to make history.

The other, attorney Ann Kirkpatrick, who is also from Flagstaff, hopes history repeats itself.

Benally Baldenegro was born and raised in Kayenta on the Navajo Reservation.

She has a degree in English literature from Arizona State University, studied law at Harvard and received a master of laws degree from the University of Arizona.

She is a strong proponent of protecting Medicare and Social Security, investing in education, supporting small business and maintaining solid intergovernmental relations with the 11 tribes in the district.

If victorious, the 34-year-old public analyst will be the first American Indian woman elected to Congress.

"A lot of folks out there are struggling to make ends meet," Benally Baldenegro said in a phone interview Wednesday. "They want to know there will be someone in Congress who is going to listen to them and work with them."

Kirkpatrick, 62, was born in McNary and raised on the White Mountain Apache Indian Reservation.

She is an alumna of the UA College of Law and has served in government at both the state and national level, including a congressional term in District 1.

Kirkpatrick was elected to the seat in 2008 but was defeated by the current U.S. representative for the district, Paul Gosar, in 2010.

This time around she's running in a largely reconfigured district thanks to a controversial decennial redistricting process.

During her time in office, Kirkpatrick voted for the 2009 economic stimulus package, as well as the 2010 Affordable Care Act.

Like Benally Baldenegro, she supports funding higher education, sustaining Medicare and Social Security and strengthening business development, particularly along the Interstate 10 corridor.

"People are frustrated with partisan gridlock," Kirkpatrick said. "During my last term in office, we were actually making progress to get things done."

Both Kirkpatrick and Benally Baldenegro say job growth in the mostly rural District 1, which runs from northern Pima County up the east end of the state to the Utah border, is the biggest concern for voters.

Benally Baldenegro said she would work toward receiving funds from the recently enacted surface transportation bill, otherwise known as the Moving Ahead for Progress in the 21st Century Act, as a way to create jobs.

The bill, among other things, provides continued financial support for infrastructure improvement projects on highways, roads and bridges.

"We have such an aging infrastructure," she said. "If we could get those dollars into the local economy, we would be able to help put people back to work right away."

Kirkpatrick's jobs plan revolves around creating a diversified economy that isn't dependent on any one sector.

She envisions bringing more new and emerging technology industries - such as biotech, wind and solar energy - to the district.

She also wants jobs created by what she calls "federal action, not federal dollars" and cites the Four Forest Restoration Initiative that she helped broker while in Congress as an example.

The initiative thins out trees in the Apache-Sitgreaves, Kaibab, Coconino, and Apache national forests to restore fire-adapted ecosystems.

"That creates jobs, but it also protects our forests from the horrific wildfires that we've had in the past," Kirkpatrick said.

 

Contact reporter Gerald M. Gay at ggay@azstarnet.com or 807-8430.

Health law repeal, jobs are issues for 3 GOP hopefuls

The race to replace U.S. Rep. Paul Gosar in the upcoming Congressional District 1 election has yielded three Republican candidates, including one familiar to Southern Arizonans.

Jonathan Paton is making his second run for Congress after his failed attempt to win District 8 in 2010.

Paton is a Tucson native who spent two terms in the Arizona House of Representatives and one in the Arizona Senate.

In the mostly rural District 1, which runs from northern Pima County up the east end of the state to the Utah border, Paton is squaring off against two relative newcomers to Arizona politics: Patrick Gatti from Show Low; and Gaither Martin from Eagar.

On Sunday evening, Doug Wade from Sedona announced he was dropping out of the race and endorsing Martin. In a news release announcing his decision, Wade said it was important for he and Martin to work together to ensure a Republican victory, as they both have strong name recognition in Northern Arizona.

Gatti, 69, moved to Show Low from La Verne, Calif., in 2008. There, he ran a flower shop and served on the La Verne city council for 21 years.

Gatti said his decision to run for Congress has been building for some time.

"I don't understand how a country like ours can go for three years without a budget," Gatti said. "I always had a budget. It seems like such a simple thing."

Gatti said he believes in a flat tax and strongly opposes government bailouts.

He hopes to build jobs if elected, but also to cut down on big government, by working to eliminate organizations such as the Environmental Protection Agency, the IRS and the U.S. Department of Education.

"Do we need a federal Department of Education?" Gatti asked. "We already have one here in Arizona. There are functions that could easily be turned over to the states rather than having another layer of federal oversight."

Martin, 37, has family that goes back five generations in CD1, as well as a unique professional background.

The Brigham Young University graduate worked at the U.S. Embassy in Baghdad, Iraq, starting in 2004 as the chief of staff of the embassy's information management unit. He then worked as a senior adviser to the Iraqi minister of planning.

Martin said he believes his time in Iraq allowed him to better grasp U.S. issues in foreign policy, national security and appropriations.

Martin said he would work to rein in federal spending. He supports domestic energy independence and wants to limit government overreach, especially from organizations such as the Environmental Protection Agency, which he feels has stifled job growth at power plants throughout the district through strict regulations.

"We need to make sure that we make choices that are smart for the environment," he said. "At the same time, we need to make sure we are not crippling the economy when we do."

Paton's experience in the Legislature has helped make him the favored candidate in the primary elections.

As a state representative, Paton voted for the immigration bill SB1070 and sponsored a law that specifically targeted human smugglers.

He was the driving force behind a bill that exempted active-duty Reserve and National Guard personnel from state income taxes.

He also worked to reform government transparency, something that he hopes to carry on at the federal level.

"People need to know what their government is up to, what they are doing," he said.

Paton said the No. 1 concern of voters from his district is job growth, which he feels can be achieved by repealing the Affordable Care Act, lowering taxes for small businesses and limiting regulations on industries that have a significant presence in District 1.

"My job is to be the guy to stick up for people in their fight with the federal government," Paton said.

Contact reporter Gerald M. Gay at ggay@azstarnet.com or 807-8430.

Candidate Q&A: US Congressional District 1

Jonathan Paton

How does someone represent such a large, far-flung district with so many divergent interests?

It's critical to reach all parts of the district, as every area has unique needs. I've put 50,000 miles on my car traveling the district, meeting with voters so I can effectively represent them. We have the opportunity to have three representatives from Southern Arizona for the first time. I'm proud to be endorsed by local leaders like Marana Mayor Ed Honea because they know I understand Southern Arizona.

What if anything would you do to ensure the long-term stability of Social Security and Medicare?

The first thing I would do is repeal ObamaCare, which will cut more than $500 billion from Medicare. My opponent Ann Kirkpatrick voted for Obama-Care and continues to defend leaving the entire law in place, including those cuts in Medicare. In order to strengthen and secure Medicare, we must repeal ObamaCare.

Cite three things you would do to increase the number of jobs in the district.

1) Repeal and replace Obama-Care so that small businesses can begin hiring again;

2) Stop regulations that are hurting Arizona industries like mining, forestry and energy;

3) Keep taxes low on small businesses, which are the lifeblood of our economy.

Do you support some version of the Dream Act, and if so, on what terms.

I disagree with President Obama on a fundamental principle: He believes the president has the power to ignore and disregard laws passed by Congress when it is politically expedient. If President Obama wants to change federal immigration policy, he needs to ask Congress, and Congress needs to debate those changes in front of the American people.

Patrick Gatti

How does someone represent such a large, far-flung district with so many divergent interests ?

Each county deserves to receive the attention that any other area would receive. That is accomplished by visiting as many spots within an area as possible on a monthly basis.

The problem, I believe, is once in Washington, D.C., our representatives become comfortable in that arena and choose not to return to their district for fear of making a mistake of some sort.

What if anything would you do to ensure the long-term stability of Social Security and Medicare ?

I would pursue and vote for the ability of the individual to invest a portion of their tax in a fund that they cannot touch until their established retirement age. I would also work towards getting the government to return the money that was borrowed twice from the Social Security fund.

Cite three things you would do to increase the number of jobs in the district.

Jobs in CD1, as in any other district, are all attached to the health of the economy. Restrictions and regulations imposed by the government must be removed or changed so businesses are able to open or expand, putting people to work.

Second, instead of letting banks sell off homes for less than the unpaid loan and write off the difference, reduce all home values to reflect the actual market and renegotiate the loans to that level, allowing current owners a chance to make lower payments and keep their homes.

Do you support some version of the Dream Act, and if so, on what terms.

It's easy to respond with a no, but I believe legislation designed in an election year is generally ill-conceived, just by virtue of suggesting a portion be accepted. Immigration needs to be addressed, but only after the border has been secured. If we don't do it now, we will surely be at this again in 30 years.

Wenona Benally Baldenegro

How does someone represent such a large, far-flung district with so many divergent interests ?

CD1 is a primarily rural district, which is the commonality that binds it together. I was born and raised in rural Arizona, and I connect with the constituents of CD1.

My diverse array of endorsements is testament to the support that I have. I have been endorsed by, among others, Rep. Raúl Grijalva, Sierra Club Arizona, the United Steelworkers of America, and eight Indian tribes, including the Navajo Nation and San Carlos Apache Tribe.

What if anything would you do to ensure the long-term stability of Social Security and Medicare?

Social Security and Medicare do not contribute to the deficit, and in fact, Social Security has generated a $2.6 trillion surplus. I will reject GOP efforts to privatize these programs, and to balance our budget on the backs of our nation's seniors and retirees, who have paid into these vital programs, their whole lives, and who have earned these benefits.

Cite three things you would do to increase the number of jobs in the district.

First, I will work to pass the American Jobs Act, which is a comprehensive plan to create job growth. Second, I will bring infrastructure and transportation projects to Arizona, which will immediately create jobs. Third, I will aggressively pursue solar energy development, which will boost our economy and create jobs for Arizonans.

Do you support some version of the Dream Act, and if so, on what terms.

I support the DREAM Act. I support creating a path to citizenship for these young people who were brought here, as children, and who have worked hard, excelled and are going on to college or to serve in the armed forces. They are Americans, in every sense, and they are driven and motivated to give back to this country that is their home.

Ann Kirkpatrick

How does someone represent such a large, far-flung district with so many divergent interests?

It comes down to knowing the people you are representing and knowing how to find common ground. I've lived and served in nearly every corner of CD1 - these folks are my neighbors. I'm the only candidate with proven experience in tackling the issues and logistics of a district this size.

What if anything would you do to ensure the long-term stability of Social Security and Medicare?

I oppose dismantling Medicare or creating a voucher system. We can't stick seniors with the tab when we reform entitlements or balance the budget. Let's restore fiscal responsibility and lower the deficit the right way, by standing up for the middle class and having millionaires and corporations pay their fair share.

Cite three things you would do to increase the number of jobs in the district.

1) Encourage a stable, diversified economy by helping emerging industries like biotech reach potential.

2) Secure resources for universities and colleges, which are critical to our economy but have had devastating cuts.

3) Focus on economic development such as infrastructure along I-10's transportation corridor or protecting environmental treasures and economic drivers like the Grand Canyon.

Do you support some version of the Dream Act, and if so, on what terms.

Yes, because it provides a fair, sensible process for young people who were brought here as children and are now working hard and playing by the rules. The DREAM Act is endorsed by fair-minded people across our nation - from Pentagon officials to editorial boards to Republicans and Democrats alike.

Related to this collection

Arizona Daily Star
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Bluesky
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Arizona Daily Star Store
  • This is Tucson
  • Saddlebag Notes
  • Tucson Festival of Books
Prefer us on Google

Sites & Partners

  • E-edition
  • Classifieds
  • Events calendar
  • Careers @ Lee Enterprises
  • Careers @ USA Today Co.
  • Online Features
  • Sponsored Blogs
  • Get Healthy

Services

  • Advertise with us
  • Register
  • Contact us
  • RSS feeds
  • Newsletters
  • Photo reprints
  • Subscriber services
  • Subscription FAQ
  • Licensing
  • Shopping

© Copyright 2026 Arizona Daily Star, PO Box 26887 Tucson, AZ 85726-6887

A Lee Enterprises, Incorporated newspaper. Majority shareholder: David Hoffmann, Hoffmann Media Group.

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Advertising Terms of Use | Do Not Sell My Info | Cookie Preferences

Powered by BLOX Content Management System from bloxdigital.com.

  • Notifications
  • Settings
You don't have any notifications.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.

Topics

News Alerts

Breaking News