George Schmidt won’t forget the day Ryan Fitzpatrick moved to the neighborhood.
The Hamburg resident had finished playing hockey with his 8-year-old son, climbed the steps from his basement and stopped dead in his tracks.
“We came upstairs and Ryan Fitzpatrick and Trent Edwards are in the kitchen, and my wife’s cooking food,” Schmidt said. “I’m like, ‘Uhhhh, maybe you want to come and tell me that you’ve got two Buffalo Bills quarterbacks in our kitchen?’
“When Ryan moved in, they never hooked up the stove right. They put the food in the oven and it wasn’t cooking, so they brought it over to finish cooking their meal.”
Fitzpatrick, 37, never had a winning record in his four seasons with the Bills after replacing Edwards as the starter midway through the 2009 season. A seventh-round draft pick from Harvard cast off by the Rams and Bengals, Fitzpatrick went 20-33 while tossing 80 touchdowns and 64 interceptions during his tenure in Buffalo, part of the Bills’ 17-year playoff drought between 1999 and 2017, then the longest active streak of futility in major North American pro sports.
Fitzpatrick’s time here was highlighted by a 21-point comeback victory against the Patriots in 2011. A couple of weeks later, he signed a six-year contract extension for $59 million, including $29 million guaranteed, a deal that then had the potential to become the richest in franchise history. But “The Amish Rifle” – he coined the nickname, playing off his distinctive lumberjack beard – was released less than two years later, in the midst of a major housecleaning, when the Bills fired Chan Gailey and hired Doug Marrone as head coach.
Fitzpatrick will start against the Bills on Sunday at Hard Rock Stadium; the Dolphins are his eighth NFL franchise in 16 seasons. But the eternal underdog remains beloved by Bills Mafia because of his fun-loving attitude, fearless play, endless effort, grittiness, selflessness and down-to-earth demeanor, along with his steadfast adulation for the City of Good Neighbors.
Earlier this month, Bills fans donated more than $15,000 to the Concussion Legacy Foundation in honor of Fitzpatrick’s mother, Lori, who died Aug. 29.
They came in $14 increments, because Fitzpatrick wears No. 14.
“During a dark time, during the drought, he was one of the bright spots for fans,” said Del Reid, the #BillsMafia co-founder and owner of 26 Shirts, explaining the enduring love for Fitzpatrick. “He had that gunslinger mentality. He was following Trent Edwards, who a lot of people used to call ‘Captain Checkdown’ and used to get frustrated with his conservative play. And maybe that wasn’t Edwards’ fault. Maybe that was the game planning. But when you remove Edwards and you put in place this guy who is not afraid to throw the ball, fans were excited to have any kind of vertical passing action going on with the offense.”
“Buffalo is naturally drawn to the underdog, the discarded, the forgotten,” said Luke Russert, the former NBC News Washington correspondent and lifelong Bills fan. “Embracing a journeyman from the Ivy League who overcame the odds to make the NFL was a natural fit for the fanbase. Fitz was also incredibly gritty as evidenced by playing out a season with a broken rib. … Till that point the Bills hadn't had an honest QB since Drew Bledsoe, meaning with Fitz, you knew what you had and you were happy to roll with it. There was no ‘future potential’ or ‘great physical skills that just need fine-tuning.’ He lacked athleticism, was a bit undersized and could be too much of gunslinger, but dammit he gave 100% and never looked unprepared. You trusted him.”
“He was an adventure to watch – both good and bad,” said Nick Bakay, an actor, writer, sports commentator and Buffalo native, “but such a shot of adrenaline to our collective coma during the Dick Jauron years.”
As much as Buffalo fans still love Fitzpatrick, he loves them back.
"There are very few places where during the football season your mood is based on what happened last Sunday, and that's what Buffalo is," Fitzpatrick said before last season's game in Orchard Park. "It's such a special place to play, and when you are a player there, you really do appreciate the fans and how much they are into it."
Fitzpatrick has played for the Rams, Bengals, Bills, Titans, Texans, Jets, Buccaneers and Dolphins.
Buffalo was his third and longest stop, from 2009 to ’12.
It’s where the Arizona native first grew his trademark beard, where he was briefly regarded as the franchise quarterback, where his legend was born.
“I saw him go from the person who nobody really recognized to ‘FitzMagic,’ ” former Bills wide receiver Stevie Johnson said.
A fellow former seventh-round draft pick, Johnson eclipsed 1,000 receiving yards in three seasons with Fitzpatrick and signed a long-term extension just a year before the quarterback was jettisoned.
Johnson said the Bills moved on from Fitzpatrick a year too early.
“We should have just got rid of Doug Marrone. Or Chan Gailey,” Johnson said, venting frustration over the tumultuous 2013 offseason. “I don’t understand the move. It was a crazy move where they bring in the guy, Doug Marrone, and he just bullies the situation with the offense. It was just crazy. And then they get rid of Fitz.”
But after four seasons, it was clear to most observers the ride was over.
“He got a big contract and I don’t think he would even try to tell you that he was performing at the level of that contract,” veteran Bills radio broadcaster John Murphy said about Fitzpatrick. “And I’m not speaking for the Bills here, but I think at the time the sense was, ‘OK, we’ve gone about as far as we can go with this guy and we should try somebody else.’ And so they did. And it took them a while to get to Josh (Allen), obviously, but both sides, I think, came to the realization that it was time.”
Fitzpatrick’s ascent began when Edwards was benched in 2009. He went 4-4 and in his third start tossed a franchise record 98-yard touchdown to Terrell Owens in a loss to the Jaguars.
The next season, Buffalo lost its first eight games under Gailey, the team’s fifth head coach in 10 years.
But Fitzpatrick, who again replaced Edwards as the starter after Week 2, twice threw four touchdowns in a game, including in a 49-31 comeback victory against the Bengals, when the Bills erased a 21-point deficit and Johnson caught three touchdowns in the second half.
“We were in the huddle and I asked (Fitzpatrick) if he’d ever made a comeback and he was like, ‘I got close when I was with the Rams,’ ” Johnson said. “And then he was like, ‘Let’s make it happen today.’ And when we did it, I was like, ‘This dude, he’s serious.’ He don’t just talk about, ‘Yeah, I’ll get you the ball.’ He actually does it. He gives you that opportunity. That’s why he’s so good.”
But his gunslinging style was just as likely to backfire in a spate of turnovers.
The Bills finished the season with a 4-12 record and the No. 3 pick in the draft, missing out on the chance to select Cam Newton first overall.
(The Panthers finished 2-14. The Bengals were likewise 4-12.)
But Fitzpatrick’s strong finish, coupled with his charisma and a fast start the following season captured the hearts of Bills fans and teammates.
“Fitz is at the top of most people’s list when you get to play with him,” former Bills center and current broadcaster Eric Wood said. “He’s just so selfless. He has no ego, and he plays like that, and that shows up when he prepares so hard, puts so much heart and soul into the game plan, and then he goes out and puts his body on the line during the game. He’s reckless out there, in a good way, trying to run over people. He’s 37 years old. And he’s a ton of fun to play with, and guys appreciate guys like that in this league.”
The Bills surged to a 5-2 record in 2011, a run that included a 21-point comeback to stun the Patriots, 34-31, in Week 3 in Orchard Park.
Buffalo, which improved to 3-0, hadn’t beaten the Patriots since 2003, a run of 15 consecutive losses over eight years.
“That win was akin to a playoff victory,” Russert said. “It exorcised many demons that had haunted the franchise for the 2000s and fanned the flames of hope that carried on till the postseason drought was finally broken in 2017.”
Fitzpatrick signed his extension just six games into the season. But after a Week 8 shutout victory against Washington, the Bills lost seven straight games and went 1-8 the rest of the way, finishing at 6-10.
Fitzpatrick threw for a career-high 3,832 yards and 24 touchdowns, but also led the league with 23 interceptions. After the season, a teammate disclosed that Fitzpatrick had broken a rib against Washington, but the quarterback never missed a game.
“There is so much about Ryan Fitzpatrick that embodies Western New York and Bills fans in general,” said Ryan Nobles, a CNN Washington correspondent and lifelong fan. “He was always every team’s second choice, so when he emerged as the Bills' starter and won some big games – like crushing the Patriots in 2011 – it was the perfect marriage between an underrated quarterback and an underrated fan base. The fact that he continues to defy expectations is a credit to his hard work and unbelievable perseverance. It is hard for me to root for anyone in a Dolphins uniform, but I will always root for Fitz.”
"He plays his butt off every week, has fun and is quick to forget mistakes,” said Jeff Glor, the CBS journalist and Tonawanda native.
“Fitz was always so polite to fans,” said Robyn Mundy, the editor-in-chief of BillsMafia.com. “Once when I was sitting in a waiting area at Customs entering St. Lucia I noticed Fitz was on the other side of the room with a small group of people. I pulled out my Bills bucket hat and put it on. He looked over at me, gave me a thumbs-up and went on about his business. Years later at a Bills game in Denver we met again. He remembered and chuckled about our chance encounter in the Eastern Caribbean years prior. A truly genuine person on and off the field.”
Fitzpatrick, now a father of seven, often joined his neighbors for cookouts after home games.
“We’d be at the house just chilling, playing family games like Pictionary and Charades, and everybody in the neighborhood is cool with coming around his house,” said Johnson, who lived a couple of blocks away. “It’s not like it was blocked off or private. He was like a regular, cool dad, but he was like slanging touchdowns. It was sweet.”
Johnson signed a five-year, $36.25 million contract extension in March 2012, a week before he was to become an unrestricted free agent, keeping Fitzpatrick’s favorite target in the fold.
But the Bills kept losing games.
Buffalo posted another 6-10 record in 2012, with Fitzpatrick starting all 16 games for the second consecutive season. Excitement waned, with the team failing to sell out its final four home games.
Gailey was fired by the Bills on New Year’s Eve, after three losing seasons. A week later, the Bills hired Marrone, now in his fourth season as head coach of the Jaguars. In March 2013, they released Fitzpatrick, a day before he was due a $3 million bonus.
He called into the John Murphy Show later that night.
“Sometimes you’ve got to twist people’s arms to get them on the show in a situation like that,” Murphy said. “With Fitz it was like, ‘Of course I’ll do the show. Of course I will.’ And he’s been on the show since then a couple of times, too, just because, I don’t know, because he’s Fitz. He’s great.”
A month later, then Bills General Manager Buddy Nix traded down to draft Florida State quarterback EJ Manuel at No. 16 overall, then bolstered the wide receiving corps, adding Robert Woods in the second round and Marquise Goodwin in the third.
Nix then stepped down as GM and Doug Whaley was promoted to the role.
Johnson played one last season in Buffalo – his production nosedived while catching passes from Manuel and Thad Lewis – before being traded to the 49ers.
“We all knew inside that EJ would be even better if he sat one year underneath Fitz, you know what I’m saying?” Johnson said. “Built that up, and then he would have been cool. Even if Thad Lewis would have been playing in front of him. I think they just rushed him in there because we needed something. So we brought in a high draft pick quarterback, and the fans were loving it, but at the same time, we knew he wasn’t ready at that time.”
Fitzpatrick went 10-6 a few years later with the Jets, with Gailey as offensive coordinator and Brandon Marshall and Eric Decker his top receivers, but New York didn’t make the playoffs, losing the regular season finale, 22-17, to the Bills in Orchard Park.
“It was a bitter loss,” Murphy said. “Fitz was playing quarterback for the Jets, and I remember after the game, we were down shooting postgame stuff on the field and he was there talking to friends. It looked like his old Buffalo friends – not teammates, but neighbors – 45 minutes after the game.”
It was the only winning season in his career, the closest he’s ever come to reaching the playoffs.
“This year we met up at the Super Bowl,” Wood said, “and me, him and one of his neighbors from Buffalo, we had plans of going to a party that night and meeting up with some people, and we ended up just talking and hanging out for about six hours and blowing off all plans. With a guy like that, you just enjoy being around him.”
Fitzpatrick returned to Buffalo for a day in 2018 to support Wood when the center announced his retirement from football because of a neck injury.
He again returned a couple of weeks later for WGR’s Roast of Fred Jackson, when, during his bit as a featured speaker, he famously stripped to his Zubaz undies at the podium.
Fitzpatrick went 5-8 in 13 starts last season in Miami.
He won the final two games, including the season finale in New England, again costing his franchise a shot at the No. 1 overall pick, in this case the opportunity to draft LSU quarterback Joe Burrow.
“That’s the thing with Ryan Fitzpatrick. He’s dangerous,” Reid said. “You put him on the field, you don’t know what’s going to happen, and it seems franchise after franchise keeps picking him up just to be like this placeholder. The dude’s dangerous on the field and anytime he can turn on that FitzMagic and he can light you up. It’s crazy. But then he’ll also throw three picks. So you play with fire. But sometimes it works.”
The Dolphins drafted his eventual successor, Tua Tagovailoa, with the No. 5 overall pick, but also coaxed Gailey out of retirement this offseason, hiring him as offensive coordinator and pairing him with Fitzpatrick for the third time in their careers.
Fitzpatrick began his 16th NFL season last week by throwing no touchdowns and three interceptions in a 21-11 loss at New England. It’s only a matter of time before he’s replaced.
But Johnson thinks Fitzpatrick could continue playing for several years.
“At quarterback, you can do that if you know how to protect yourself and you know how to give your guys opportunities,” Johnson said. “I could see him playing for 20-plus maybe, if he wants to.”
Wherever he goes, Bills fans will continue to root for his success.
“I love the guy,” Reid said. “I want him to win all the time, except when he plays the Bills, so here’s hoping he throws four picks and the Dolphins get embarrassed.”