Skip to main contentSkip to main content
Register for more free articles.
Log in Sign up
Back to homepage
Subscriber Login
Keep reading with a digital access subscription.
Subscribe now
You have permission to edit this collection.
Edit
Arizona Daily Star
108°
  • Sign in
  • Subscribe Now
  • Manage account
  • Logout
    • Manage account
    • e-Newspaper
    • Logout
  • News
    • Sign up for newsletters
    • Local
    • Arizona
    • Business
    • Crime
    • Nation & World
    • Markets & Stocks
    • SaddleBrooke
    • Politics
    • Archives
    • News Tip
  • Arizona Daily Star
    • E-edition
    • E-edition-Tutorial
    • Archives
    • Special Sections
    • Merchandise
    • Circulars
    • Readers' Choice Awards
    • Buyer's Edge
  • Obituaries
    • Share Your Story
    • Recent Obituaries
    • Find an Obituary
  • Opinion
    • Submit a Letter
    • Submit guest opinion
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Opinion & Editorials
    • National Columnists
  • Sports
    • Arizona Wildcats
    • Greg Hansen
    • High Schools
    • Roadrunners
  • Lifestyles
    • Events Calendar
    • Arts & Theatre
    • Food & Cooking
    • Movies & TV
    • Movie Listings
    • Music
    • Comics
    • Games
    • Columns
    • Play
    • Home & Gardening
    • Health
    • Get Healthy
    • Parenting
    • Fashion
    • People
    • Pets
    • Travel
    • Faith
    • Retro Tucson
    • History
    • Travel
    • Outdoors & Rec
    • Community Pages
  • Brand Ave. Studios
  • Join the community
    • News tip
    • Share video
  • Buy & Sell
    • Place an Ad
    • Shop Local
    • Jobs
    • Homes
    • Marketplace
    • I Love A Deal
  • Shopping
  • Customer Service
    • Manage My Account
    • Newsletter Sign-Up
    • Subscribe
    • Contact us
  • Mobile Apps
  • Weather: Live Radar
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Bluesky
  • YouTube
  • Pinterest
  • Instagram
© 2026 Lee Enterprises
Terms of Service | Privacy Policy
Arizona Daily Star
News+
Read Today's E-edition
Arizona Daily Star
News+
  • Log In
  • $1 for 3 months
    Subscribe Now
    • Manage account
    • e-Newspaper
    • Logout
  • E-edition
  • News
  • Obituaries
  • Opinion
  • Wildcats
  • Lifestyles
  • Newsletters
  • Comics & Puzzles
  • Readers' Choice Awards
  • Jobs
  • 108° Sunny
Share This
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Bluesky
  • WhatsApp
  • SMS
  • Email

Candidates for Arizona Legislative offices

  • Oct 11, 2010
  • Oct 11, 2010 Updated Nov 2, 2010
Prefer us on Google

Profiles of the legislative races.

Taxes, education hot issues for LD 30 Senate contenders

Though there's a Republican voter-registration advantage in Legislative District 30, state Sen. Frank Antenori says he isn't resting on his laurels.

And the same voter-registration advantage isn't deterring Democrat Todd Camenisch from challenging Antenori for his seat.

Antenori brings his Army Special Forces background into the race. He said he takes no prisoners when running for election and goes all out in his campaigning. He's known for being blunt and strong-willed about his values and says he's no party puppet. When state party leadership wanted to cut education funding, Antenori said, he and others came up with an alternative. Though the education budget still took a hit, it was smaller because of his work, he said.

Camenisch's background as a Navy corpsman and emergency medical technician also makes regular campaign appearances. He approaches the job with the motto "first, do no further harm," especially when discussing education. He disagrees that Antenori saved education from harmful budget cuts, and, as a member of the Catalina Foothills School District governing board, he said the cuts were "easy" and "mean."

Antenori's priority in the Senate is to reduce the business property tax, to encourage investment here. He'd like to couple that with a flat income tax of between 3.9 and 4.2 percent and allow people no more than two deductions.

"It creates a stable tax base so we're less reliant on the sales tax, which is a huge problem right now, which is what got us into this mess," he said.

He also said he has proven he will work across the aisle, because he helped Democratic Sen. Meg Burton Cahill get a bill passed to bring Arizona in line with the Americans with Disabilities Act, and he helped Rep. Matt Heinz, also a Democrat, get a bill through allowing liquor sales at 6 a.m. on Sundays.

Camenisch said his top priority is education.

"I'm not a single-issue person, but we'll never get out of this crisis without paying for education," he said. Creating jobs and improving education go hand-in-hand, he said.

He often references tax loopholes that prevent the state from collecting some $10 billion in revenue.

He also said legislation isn't about party, because all people want the same things, including a good education for their children.

Frank Antenori

Party: Republican

Age: 44

Occupation: Program manager, defense industry; State senator; published author

Education: Bachelor of health science with minor in biology, Campbell University; nationally registered EMT/paramedic, University of Texas at San Antonio

Past elected public offices: Arizona House of Representatives 2008, precinct committeeman 2006

Civic activities: Founding member and board member of Task Force Dagger Foundation, which helps Army Special Operations soldiers and their families; Veterans of Foreign Wars

Top endorsements: Arizona Chamber of Commerce and Industry, National Rifle Association A+.

Top priority: Reforming tax code to entice businesses to Arizona; creating jobs.

Web address: www.vote4frank.com

Todd Camenisch

Party: Democrat

Age: 42

Occupation: Associate professor, University of Arizona College of Pharmacy

Education: Bachelor of science, University of Arizona 1990; Ph.D., University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill 1998

Past elected public offices: Catalina Foothills School Board 2008

Civic activities: Founder, state chapter Children's Heart Association; FFC and Ft. Lowell soccer coach; CFSD classroom volunteer

Top endorsements: Pima County Sheriff Clarence Dupnik, UA President Emeritus John Schaefer, Army Brig. Gen. John Adams

Top priority: Improving public education and creating jobs with targeted tax credits for small and midsize businesses.

Web address: azvote4todd.com

Jobs, economy focus in Dist. 30 House race

Jobs and the economy are center stage in the race for two House seats in Legislative District 30.

The east-side district's incumbents, Republicans David Gowan and Ted Vogt, want to create jobs for unemployed Arizonans, and they want to do that by restructuring the state's tax code to be more business friendly.

Challenger Andrea Dalessandro, a Democrat, says she can use her accounting background to restore education funding, but she also wants to ensure local communities stay safe and individuals have what she calls "real freedom." She ran for the same office in 2008.

"It's about people living life to the full potential," she said.

Gowan, who is seeking his second term in the Arizona House, says he kept the promises he made during his first campaign to protect families, reduce the size of government and fight illegal immigration.

"And I plan to go up there to the Legislature and continue doing what we need to do to make sure we get our state back in order. The only way we're going to do that is reducing the size of government and reforming our tax structure," Gowan said.

Vogt was appointed to his seat in March after then-Rep. Frank Antenori was appointed to fill a vacancy in the state Senate.

He said he wants to get jobless Arizonans back to work.

"People work hard and make money and should be allowed to keep what they earn," he said.

Gowan and Vogt say they want to reduce business income taxes to allow small businesses to put more of their profit into their companies. Both also say the state may need to ask departments to justify funding sought so lawmakers can better prioritize.

Dalessandro said she would agree to lowering business property taxes, but only after some of the loopholes are eliminated.

Andrea Dalessandro

Party: Democrat

Age: 63

Occupation: retired tax accountant

Education: Bachelor of arts and master of arts in mathematics education, City University of New Jersey; master of business administration in professional accounting, Rutgers University.

Past elected public offices: county precinct committeewomen, state party committeewoman

Civic activities: member, Valle Verde Rotary; charter member, Sahuarita Elks; senior committee, United Way; League of Women Voters; member, Public Safety Retirement Board for Sahuarita Police Department

Top endorsements: Arizona Education Association, Arizona Conference of Police and Sheriffs, Arizona Nurses Association

Top priority: Increase opportunity, border security and real freedom.

Web address www.andreaforaz.net or 648-2092

David Gowan

Party: Republican

Age: 41

Occupation: State Representative, District 30

Past elected public office: Precinct committeeman

Education: Bachelor of arts in education social studies, University of Arizona; Associate of arts in general studies, Cochise College.

Civic activities: Chairman of Boy Scouts Troop 408, martial arts instructor, Elks Lodge 2065 Member

Top endorsements: National Federation of Independent Business, Tucson Chamber of Commerce, Southern Arizona Home Builders Association

Top priority: Get Arizona's economy working on all cylinders again.

Web address: www.gowanforaz.com

Ted Vogt

Party: Republican

Age: 37

Occupation: Law clerk, Smith & Smith, PLLC

Education: B.A., Yale University; J.D., University of Arizona

Past elected public offices: Republican precinct committeeman

Civic activities: Veterans of Foreign Wars

Top endorsements: National Rifle Association, National Federation of Independent Business, Arizona Right to Life

Top priority: Get the state's economy moving forward again.

Web address www.vogt4arizona.com

Dist. 29 House Dems vs. GOP challenger

Two Democratic incumbents are trying to stave off the challenge of a seasoned Republican in the race for the two House of Representatives seats in Arizona's Legislative District 29.

Both Matt Heinz and Daniel Patterson are one-term representatives who were elected to seats vacated because of term limits in 2008. Republican Pat Kilburn, who ran against the pair last election, is trying to earn his first major elected public office.

District 29 runs east from South 12th Ave. to Houghton Rd. and south from 22nd Street past I-10. The district has twice as many registered Democrats as Republicans, and 6,000 more independents.

Kilburn has repeatedly criticized increased state spending dating back to former Gov. Janet Napolitano, saying spending increased 62 percent during her time as governor from 2002 to 2008. Patterson and Heinz, while admitting spending must be curbed, have said some programs must be retained regardless of cost. Both cited the Arizona "First Things First" fund as an example, criticizing Kilburn for supporting Proposition 302, which would take $340 million from a special fund earmarked for use in early-childhood development and education programs and place into state discretionary spending.

All three candidates have noted the importance of state education funding, and Heinz has said the economic benefits of an educated populace far outweigh the initial costs of education funding. Patterson blamed the Republican Legislature for repeatedly taking the "axe" to education. Kilburn blamed rising administration costs, which grossly outpace growth in enrollment, as the primary culprit.

Patterson has accused House Republicans of trying to exclude Democrats from important votes by holding them at late hours with little notice, something he said put an undue burden to both him and Heinz, who have to commute to Phoenix when the Legislature is in session. Kilburn has said bipartisan cooperation would be a point of emphasis if he is elected.

All three candidates have said they would not be intimidated by representatives from Maricopa County, who constitute a substantial portion of the Legislature. Heinz and Patterson cited their past voting records as proof of this, though they both referred to Maricopa representatives as "bullies." Kilburn has said he recognizes the issue, but he would refuse to let himself be intimidated and would put the needs of the district ahead of the party line.

Matt Heinz

Party: Democratic

Age: 33

Occupation: Physician

Education: Albion College, 1999, & Wayne State University, 2003 (MD)

Past elected public offices: State representative since 2008

Civic activities: American Medical Association, Equality Arizona, Health Arizona Initiative

Top endorsements: Arizona Medical Association, Arizona Association of Realtors, Sierra Club

Top priority: Getting Arizona's jobs and economy going again.

Web address: www.Heinz forArizona.com

Pat Kilburn

Party: Republican

Age: 63

Occupation: Retired federal agent, small-business owner

Education: B.A. in economics and political science, University of Montana

Past elected public offices: None

Civic activities: Finance officer Military Order of the Purple Heart, Vietnam Veterans of America, Veterans Administration Veterans Service

Top endorsements: Arizona Association of Realtors, Arizona Technical Council, Arizona Sportsmen for Wildlife

Top priority: Jobs, education, public safety, reducing fraud, waste and abuse

Web address: www.vote kilburn.com

Daniel Patterson

Party: Democratic

Age: 39

Occupation: State representative, ecologist and Southwest director, Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility

Education: Michigan State University, B.S. natural and agriculture policy and law and in environmental communications, both in 1994

Past elected public offices: State representative, two years.

Civic activities: Volunteer and speaking in schools; support veterans, children and seniors; conserve wildlife, parks and public lands

Top endorsements: Arizona Technology Council, Arizona Conference of Police and Sheriffs (AZCOPS), Arizona Education Association

Top priority: Work hard helping Tucson jobs, economy, schools, safety and middle class.

Web address: www.Daniel Patterson.net

Luke Money is a University of Arizona journalism student apprenticing at the Star. Contact him at 573-4142 or starapprentice@azstarnet.com

Jobs central in House 28 race

Democratic state House candidates Steve Farley and Bruce Wheeler want voters to send them to Phoenix as a team, to try to fix state's abysmal public-education system, which they say is the first and most important step to creating revenue and jobs.

Farley, a two-term incumbent, and Wheeler, a former two-term city councilman who served in the legislature decades ago, are taking on Republican Ken Smalley in this north-central district that has a decided Democratic tilt, with 44.5 percent of voters registered Democrat to 26.5 percent Republican. But with 29 percent independents, no seat is guaranteed.

Fixing the state's struggling economy has become the central issue of debate between the two sides.

While Farley and Wheeler emphasize a better education system as the path to better jobs, Smalley, a small-business owner, argues the state needs to lower property taxes, business real-estate taxes and business income taxes to be competitive with neighboring states.

Wheeler said investing in public schools and the state's university system will create an employable work force and attract good businesses and jobs to the state. He uses Tucson's optics industry as an example of how investing in the state's universities can fuel economic development.

"We incentivized optics research for ten years at the university, and now Tucson is the optics capital of the world," he said. "The UA is both an educational institution and an economic engine."

Farley, the policy leader for the House Democratic Caucus, said money to improve K-12 education and fund research at the university system can be found in the $10 billion in corporate tax exemptions the Republican-controlled legislature has passed into law.

Smalley said he is the only candidate with job-creating experience to help boost the economy. He argues that Arizona government can be made more efficient and effective through additional cuts, which currently are restricted by mandates. In addition, he proposes looking to other states for ideas of how to consolidate state services and redesign the state prison system.

Smalley's fix for education focuses on redesigning the system rather than increasing funding. He said the state should focus on performance-based compensation programs and incentives to redistribute top -performing teachers into underperforming schools. Furthermore, he has said, the state's charter-school system, a cheaper and often more effective alternative to public schooling, should be allowed to flourish.

Ken Smalley

Party: Republican

Age: 65

Occupation: Retired

Education: MBA, USC

Past elected public offices: None

Civic activities: Junior Achievement volunteer. Financial adviser and treasurer of an educational foundation-Epsilon Epsilon. Advisor for startup businesses.

Top endorsements: None listed

Top priority: I am the only candidate with job-creating experience to boost our economy.

Web address: kensmalleyforrep.com/

Steve Farley

Party: Democrat

Age: 47

Occupation: Artist, owner, Steve Farley Design.

Education: BA, political science, Williams College, 1985

Past elected public offices: State representative, 2007-present

Civic activities: Creator, Broadway underpass murals. Founder, Tucsonans for Sensible Transportation. Board member, Blenman Elm Neighborhood Association

Top endorsements: Arizona Education Association. Metropolitan Tucson Chamber of Commerce. Professional Fire Fighters of Arizona

Top priority: Create good jobs and restore funding to our education system.

Web address: friendsofarley.com/

Bruce Wheeler

Party: Democrat

Age: 62

Occupation: Freelance photojournalist, retired since 2006

Education: Master's in business administration, University of Phoenix

Past elected public offices: Tucson City Council, 1987-95; AZ House, 1975-77

Civic activities: Volunteer for Love of Reading activities. Teaches photography to middle-school students. Volunteer weekend English teacher for young adults.

Top endorsements: Arizona Education Association, Professional Fire Fighters of Arizona, Planned Parenthood

Top priority: To improve the quality of public education, which is the foundation of a vibrant economy.

Webaddress: www.wheeler 2010.com/wheeler2010/

Will Ferguson is a University of Arizona journalism student apprenticing at the Star. Contact him at 573-4142 or at starapprentice@azstarnet.com

Dist. 28 Senate race: GOP hopes independents siphon votes

Republicans are taking a gamble that heavily Democratic District 28 could swing their way as two independents jump into the state Senate race, perhaps siphoning votes from incumbent Paula Aboud.

Aboud, a former teacher elected in 2006, is facing former lawmaker Ted Downing, who left the Democratic Party to run as independent; and Dave Ewoldt, a former Green Party activist now running as an independent, as well as Republican Greg Krino.

Krino, a former Air Force pilot, is betting a growing number of independent voters make the race far from a sure thing for the incumbent. He carries an endorsement from Mesa Sen. Russell Pearce, who was the author of the state's controversial new immigration law, although Krino has taken pains to tell voters he's a social moderate while fiscally conservative.

Aboud says Arizona's failing economy is linked to the state's abysmal education system, for which she blames Republicans. She calls for more investments in public education and the university system, saying she will raise the revenue by working with moderate Republicans to eliminate as much as $10 billion in tax exemptions, often characterized as "loopholes" for the corporations and the super-wealthy.

Downing, a UA professor, says his status as a nonpartisan will enable him to vote alongside both Republicans and Democrats in the Legislature. He is a proponent of a nonpartisan primary, similar to a school board, in which candidates run without a party designation.

"The two parties are as much an interest group as unions," he said. "They have wired the system against independents." [CORRECTION OCT. 15, 2010: In "GOP hopes independents siphon votes" on A4 Thursday, District 28 state Senate candidate Ted Downing said he believes both major political parties are interest groups in the same way as unions and corporations. The story may have implied he was especially critical of unions.]

Downing says his status as an independent will enable him to facilitate cooperation between partisans to fix the state's biggest problem, the economy. He says he will work with the state's congressional delegation to bring much-needed federal tax dollars to the state, noting Arizona brings back relatively little in federal tax dollars compared with neighboring states.

Krino, a law school graduate who just passed the bar exam, bases his economic platform on a simple tax code that incorporates a flat tax for individuals and businesses. He defends spending cuts as a way to avoid further damage as the economy continues to struggle to get back on track.

He says public safety, water and transportation should be given priority above education when it comes to state funding.

A competitive, free-market model for public schools will help the system to get back on track, he said.

Ewoldt, meanwhile, bases his platform on a system of sustainability that makes protecting the environment and safeguarding natural resources a priority. Ewoldt criticizes state lawmakers for giving away billions in tax breaks for corporations and special interests that ship jobs out of state.

He has said Arizona's future lies in funding education, health care and sustainable industry.

Paula Aboud

Party: Democrat

Age: 60

Occupation: Retired

Education: B.A., English, University of Arizona

Past elected public offices: State senator, 2006-present

Civic activities: Mediator, Our Town Family Services; member/chair, Richland Heights West Neighborhood; member/co-chair, Southern Arizona Stonewall Democrats

Top endorsements: Arizona Education Association, Professional Fire Fighters of Arizona

Top priority: Working together to balance our budget humanely, wisely and equitably.

Web address: www.paulaaboud.com

Ted Downing

Party: Independent, nonpartisan

Age: 67

Occupation: Professor at University of Arizona

Education: Ph.D., anthropology, Stanford University

Past elected public offices: State representative

Civic activities: Board member-ORANGE (Organized Residents Against Needless Government Encroachment); past president, American Association of University Professors, Arizona Chapter; past president, Richland Heights West Neighborhood Association

Endorsements: None listed

Top priority: Cut back partisan bickering to focus on good jobs, jobs, jobs.

Web address: www.votedowning.com

Dave Ewoldt

Party: Independent

Age: 56

Occupation: Executive director of Natural System Solutions

Education: A.D.D. in eco-psychology, Institute of Global Education

Past elected public offices: None

Civic activities: Blenman-Elm Neighborhood Association board; co-founder, nonprofit Transition Pima; public speaker on transitioning to a sustainable future

Endorsements: California Nurses Association/National Nurses Union; Dr. Paul Green, executive director of the Tucson Audubon Society

Top priority: Provide education, jobs and water necessary for a sustainable future.

Web address: www.daveforarizona.org

Greg Krino

Party: Republican

Age: 35

Occupation: Lawyer, member of the Air National Guard

Education: J.D., University of Arizona

Past elected public offices: None

Civic activities: Volunteer for an environmental-consulting firm

Endorsements: Former Rep. Jim Kolbe, Councilman Steve Kozachik, Supervisor Ray Carroll

Top priority: To create a predictable tax code that attracts jobs to Arizona.

Web address: gregkrino2010.com

Will Ferguson is a University of Arizona journalism student apprenticing at the Star. Contact him at 573-4142 or at starapprentice@azstarnet.com

Border issues generate most heat in District 27

The five candidates vying for two House seats in Legislative District 27 are an eclectic group, featuring a pastor, former professor, schoolteacher, businessman and service technician.

Their solutions to problems facing the southwest-side district are just as varied as their employment.

Given its location and heavy Hispanic population, it is no surprise that border issues have thus far generated the most heat. Democrats Sally Ann Gonzales and Macario Saldate, as well as Green Party candidate Kent Solberg, agree the federal government is responsible for finding a solution to illegal immigration.

Independent candidate Gene Chewning, a church pastor, said the federal government and private business sector could set up an office in Nogales where immigrants could seek employment in the U.S.

Republican Robert Compton favors building a wall and punishing employers who hire illegal immigrants.

The district - which has more than 40,000 Democrats to the Republicans' 16,000 - has sent only Democrats to the Legislature since 2002, a good sign for Gonzales and Saldate.

But voters will find the candidates, with the exception of Compton, share similarities in their platforms on funding public education and revamping Arizona's economy.

Chewning said he would push for higher salaries for teachers and smaller class sizes in schools.

Gonzales, a former teacher and the only candidate with previous experience in the Legislature, said the state needs to level educational opportunities for children from high poverty areas, such as District 27.

Saldate, a former University of Arizona professor, said he endorses Democratic gubernatorial candidate Terry Goddard's plan to restructure state education. That plan, which would be fleshed out for the start of the legislative session in January, includes restoring full-day kindergarten, eliminating unfunded mandates, providing mentoring for all new teachers and placing highly effective teachers equitably throughout the school districts.

Solberg, a small business owner, said efforts to privatize public education have been a mistake. He criticizes the charter school system as a drain on traditional public education and said the Legislature needs to make sure public education has sufficient resources.

Compton said he supports focusing on core subjects, placing an emphasis on teaching American values.

Compton's plan for economic recovery diverges from the pack as well. Compton said the state needs to eliminate unnecessary government regulations in order to foster a simple, more productive business climate.

Gonzales and Saldate pitch redirecting funds from $10 billion in corporate tax exemptions, also referred to as "loopholes," to support education and health care. Both Democrats say supporting higher education will be a catalyst for creating high-tech jobs.

Chewning, a former Republican legislative candidate, agrees that the state should re-examine corporate tax loopholes. He said he favors developing a plan to eliminate Arizona's dependence on foreign oil and stressed that cutting down on unnecessary bureaucracy should be a priority.

Solberg's economic recovery platform is based on a plan to develop a viable industry in alternate energy technology. His plan calls for the Legislature to fund a collaboration between the university system and private business to stimulate alternative energy job growth in Arizona.

On StarNet: For more election coverage, go to azstarnet.com/ election

Sally Ann Gonzales

• Party: Democrat

• Age: 53

• Occupation: Educator

• Education: Masters in bilingual/ Multicultural education, UA

• Past elected public offices: State representative 1996-2000, Pascua Yaqui Tribal Council, 1992-1998

• Civic activities: President of Guadalupe Community Development Corporation, 2003-present. Treasurer-Native American Directions, 2008-present.

• Top endorsements: Arizona AFL-CIO, AZList, Arizona Education Association

• Top priority: Education, health care and a balanced budget by overhauling and closing loopholes on our tax system.

• Web address: www.votesallygonzales.com

Macario Saldate

• Party: Democrat

• Age: 68

• Occupation: Director of Guadalajara Summer School

• Education: Doctorate in education, UA

• Past elected public offices: Board of Governors at Pima Community College

• Civic activities: Past board member-Chicanos Por La Causa, member-UA Hispanic Alumni Association.

• Endorsements: Pima County Sheriff Clarence Dupnik, former Supervisor Dan Eckstrom, Tucson City Councilman Richard Fimbres.

• Top priority: Fix our educational system and strengthen our economy.

• Web address: www.votemacariosaldate2010.info

Kent Solberg

• Party: Green

• Age: 63

• Occupation: Co-owner, Kent's Tools and Industrial Supplies

• Education: Master's in social work, Arizona State University

• Past elected public offices: None.

• Civic activities: Keeling Neighborhood Association member, Grant Road Merchants Association, chair and volunteer trainer of the Free Clinic of Tucson

• Endorsements: Arizona NOW, the Grand Canyon Chapter of the Sierra Club, the Arizona Green Party

• Top priority: Jobs, the economy, education and fixing the state Legislature.

• Web address: www.kent4house.org

Gene Chewning

• Party: Independent

• Age: 59

• Occupation: Church pastor

• Education: B.A. from Trinity Bible College

• Past elected public offices: None

• Civic activities: Vice commander/American Legion; chaplain for Veterans of Foreign Wars; volunteer at the VA Hospital.

• Top endorsements: Arizona Technical Council. Arizona Citizens Defense League. Pro-life.

• Top priority: Get people educated and back to work.

• Web address: www.facebook.com/pages/Vote-Gene-Chewning/10150113015285204?v=info

Robert Compton

• Party: Republican

• Age: 53

• Occupation: Technician at Hamstra Heating/Cooling

• Education: GED

• Past elected public offices: None

• Civic activities: Member of Mt. Zion Church council; member of Mt. Zion church choir.

• Top endorsements: None listed

• Top priority: I'd like to introduce a bill to address problems with identify theft

• Web address: thatcomptonguy.com

Will Ferguson is a University of Arizona journalism student apprenticing at the Star. Contact him at 573-4142 or at starapprentice@azstarnet.com

School-funding issue splits candidates in District 26 House race

The three House candidates in Legislative District 26 - covering the Foothills, Oro Valley, parts of Marana and SaddleBrooke - differ the most on education.

In a recent televised debate, incumbent state Rep. Vic Williams said while he agreed Arizona ranks low nationally in education funding, he characterized school cuts as "minimal relative to the size of the crisis" the state faced. And, he noted, Arizona ranks higher on academic achievement than it does on spending.

"Think how good we could be if we moved it up a little bit," retorted incumbent Democratic state Rep. Nancy Young Wright, who has said she's convinced Arizona's economic doldrums closely align with the less-than-robust state of public education.

Republican challenger Terri Proud chimed in that there could be more funding for classrooms if money was shifted away from school administrations.

The candidates are vying for two seats in District 26, which for the moment is one of a few in the state with split representation.

Young Wright is trying to ensure one of the seats stays Democratic. Her public focus on education traces back to 1996, when she won a seat on the Amphitheater school board and served for the next decade.

She said she's stood up to a GOP-led Legislature that she claims has attacked public education since Gov. Fife Symington made vouchers and charter schools keys to his education reform agenda nearly 20 years ago.

"I think our economy has to be front and center," she said, "but for me, that's so intertwined with education."

Young Wright said she has worked with the Republican majority in the past, such as former state Sen. Jonathan Paton and Sen. Frank Antenori on animal-related legislation. She comes from a conservative family from eastern New Mexico.

"Growing up, you had to try to find some common ground with people and you have to understand their point of view," she said. "Then you don't get hung up on areas where you can't agree - and focus on the areas where you can."

Proud believes the problem with education is not a lack of funding. Instead, she cites an Auditor General's report that found a nine-year low on the percentage of dollars funneled to the classroom, at just shy of 57 percent, which auditors suggested could be improved by cutting non-classroom costs like counselors and administrators.

She said schools should be pared down to their core elements, leaving non-academic subjects, such as art, music and sex education, for after-school programs. She also suggested prisons could save money if they didn't provide three meals a day for inmates.

And Proud's first campaign video features her and several female friends posing with guns to Charlie Daniels' "A Few More Rednecks."

Young Wright characterizes Proud as a straight shooter with views some would consider "extreme."

"I don't think my views are extreme," Proud said. "I hear a lot of labeling, but I have not been given a lot of examples. To me, an extremist is someone you can't even talk to and can't even reason with."

She admits her gun video was controversial, but Proud said she is an unabashed gun-rights activist who grew up in a hunting family.

"I wanted my daughters to have that right. Women are the first to be victimized in a gunless society," she said.

Williams has tried to stake out a middle ground, saying he provides "balanced leadership" based on a "practical-minded, common sense" approach. He voted for SB 1070, Arizona's new immigration law that Proud also supported.

And while he boasts of bringing "fiscal sanity" back to the budget with deep cuts in the face of shrinking revenues, Williams also boasts of protecting education - pointing out he voted for the state sales tax for education.

He said part of his economic solution is to continue to push deregulation, saying his private-sector background as a small-business owner gives him a voice of authority on ways to create jobs.

Contact reporter Rhonda Bodfield at 573-4243 or rbodfield@azstarnet.com

Dist. 26 Senate candidates differ on education

Incumbent Republican Sen. Al Melvin says it's a disgrace border-crossers are dying in the desert, saying workers should be coming across the line on air-conditioned buses.

His Democratic challenger in District 26, Cheryl Cage, agrees there should be a guest-worker program and strict employer sanctions.

That's pretty much where their meeting of the minds ends.

Border security is Melvin's No. 1 issue because, he said, something must be done to stop the "illegal-alien invasion" from trashing private property and running up taxpayer bills.

Cage said the Melvin-backed SB 1070 did not secure the border.

Melvin says talk of cuts decimating public education are overstated, and questions the value of all-day kindergarten, calling it free day care and a effort by former Gov. Janet Napolitano to ingratiate herself with the education lobby. "We need to balance our budget and not spend more than we make," Melvin said.

Cage said restoring vitality to Arizona's education system is the key to economic development, and bemoans the loss of all-day kindergarten and adult education. "It's important to elect someone who understands the difference between an investment and an expense," she said.

Melvin is pushing atomic energy and a desalinization plant for economic stability and energy independence, suggesting Arizona could use as many as five more plants like the Palo Verde nuclear facility west of Phoenix. He also advocates bringing a recycling facility for used nuclear fuel to the state.

He cites some unlikely allies, noting that President Obama has called such investments a necessity, while the co-founder of Greenpeace has since shifted to a pro-nuclear stance.

Cage said those ideas don't fit with Arizona. His plan "to bring nuclear waste to our beautiful state is a dangerous idea," said Cage, who favors solar energy as a way to build jobs and grow the economy.

It's a race that's being closely watched. Although there are 46,000 Republicans to about 37,000 Democrats in the district, there are also about 33,000 independent voters, making it one of the few competitive ones in the state.

The two have faced off before in this Northwest-area district, with Melvin eking out a win in 2008. Cage said it's different this time around. Last time, she got into the race late and was an unknown. And this time, she said, people have a chance to evaluate Melvin's voting record.

"We have to come back to the middle," she said. "Rarely does a good idea come from the far left or from the far right."

Melvin, too, said the political climate is different, and frames much of the race in terms of what's at stake nationally. Saying voters don't like key components of the national Democratic agenda, such as the health-care overhaul or cap-and-trade, he advises voters, "It's time to take our country back."

Melvin has pulled two items from Cage's website as examples of what he describes as her extreme views. The first is a link on her web page to a program to install solar panels in roadways. "It would bankrupt a state to do that," he said. The second is a suggested tax on golf carts of $20 a year.

Cage said those ideas are indicative of their style differences. She's a big believer in brainstorming to get a discussion going, even if every idea on a list isn't always a good one. The golf-cart tax was an example of that, while the solar panels are an intriguing idea as technology advances, she said.

"The fact he dismisses things out of hand clearly shows he is stuck in old ways and old thought patterns," she said.

Contact reporter Rhonda Bodfield at 573-4243 or rbodfield@azstarnet.com

Goals same in Dist. 25 House race

Candidates for the Arizona House of Representatives in Legislative District 25 have common goals, even if their methods of accomplishing them are as diverse as the district they hope to represent.

District 25 encompasses all of Cochise County, sweeps to the area south of Green Valley, and includes Avra Valley, part of Marana and parts of Pinal and Maricopa counties. The district is heavily rural, with a predominantly Anglo and Hispanic population of about 167,000, with registered Democrats outnumbering their Republican counterparts.

Two Democrats and two Republicans are seeking the district's two seats. Among them are one-term incumbents Patricia Fleming, a Democrat, and David Stevens, a Republican.

They are challenged by Democrat Ruben Ortega, who served in the Legislature from 1989 to 1996, and Republican Peggy Judd, a former committeewoman for Cochise County.

Education has been a priority for all candidates. Ortega, Judd and Fleming have noted a correlation between education funding and economic vitality, but Judd has said throwing money at the issue won't fix some of the inherent problems in Arizona's economic system.

All four candidates have stressed their small-town roots, citing their lives in rural Arizona as experience necessary to be attuned to the needs of a varied populace. Likewise, illegal immigration and border security have been listed as a top priority, since District 25 includes much of the Arizona-Mexico border.

The candidates disagree on how best to ensure a secure border, however, with both Ortega and Fleming expressing disapproval for SB 1070. Fleming voted against the bill in the Legislature this year. Stevens voted in favor, and Judd says that, while not ideal, the bill has drawn attention to Arizona's immigration plight and the inaction of the federal government.

David Stevens

• Running for: State representative District 25

• Party: Republican

• Age: 49

• Occupation: ArcSight software consultant, NCI Inc., legislator

• Education: Bachelor's in computer information systems, State University of New York, 1992

• Past elected public offices: State Rep., District 25

• Civic activities: Boy Scouts, PTA member, Cochise County Republican Committee

• Top endorsements: NRA, Arizona Citizens Defense League, National Federation of Independent Business

• Top priority: None submitted

• Web address: www.david stevens2010.com

Patricia V. Fleming

• Running for: State representative, District 25

• Party: Democratic

• Age: 61

• Occupation: Retired Army civilian worker; legislator

• Education: Bachelor's in business management, University of Phoenix

• Past elected public offices: State Rep., District 25

• Civic activities: League of Women Voters; National Alliance on Mental Illness; AARP Arizona

• Top endorsements: Arizona Hospital and Healthcare Association; Greater Sierra Vista Chamber of Commerce; Ariz. Education Association

• Top priority: Restore common sense; fund our schools.

• Web address: www.Pat FlemingAZ.com

Peggy Judd

• Running for: State representative District 25

• Party: Republican

• Age: 48

• Occupation: Architectural drafting and reception/ manager at Willcox Real Estate Co.

• Education: Certified architectural drafting technician from Phoenix Institute of Technology and bachelors in anthropology from UA

• Past elected public offices: None

• Civic activities: Rex Allen Days president; Willcox Parks and Recreation commissioner

• Top endorsements: Pima County Tea Party Patriots, Arizona Police Association, AZ Citizens Defense League

• Top priority: Securing the border, ending illegal immigration and growing business/jobs

• Web address: www.judd4house. blogspot.com

Ruben Ortega

• Running for: State representative District 25

• Party: Democrat

• Age: 54

• Occupation: Retired

• Education: Bachelor's in political science, ASU

• Past elected public offices: State Rep., 1989-96

• Top endorsements: League of United Latin American Citizens, National Alliance on Mental Illness of Southeastern AZ, Nature Conservancy

• Top priority: Prompt constituent service, bipartisanship

• Web address: www.ortega 2010.com

Border No. 1 in Dist. 25 Senate race

The Senate race in Arizona's Legislative District 25 pits a one-term incumbent trying to hold onto his seat against a former House member trying to return to the Legislature after almost a decade.

The candidates are Dem-ocratic incumbent Manny Alvarez and Republican challenger Gail Griffin. Both are former members of the state House of Representatives - Alvarez from 2003 until 2008 (when he was elected to his current Senate seat) and Griffin from 1997 until 2000.

District 25 encompasses all of Cochise County, sweeps to the area south of Green Valley, and includes Avra Valley, part of Marana and portions of Pinal and Maricopa counties. The district is heavily rural, with a predominantly Anglo and Hispanic population of about 167,000, with registered Democrats outnumbering their Republican counterparts.

Both Alvarez and Griffin have listed border security among their top priorities if they are elected. Alvarez voted no on SB 1070 and HB 2281, the ethnic-studies bill, but Griffin has said that SB 1070 is an important first step toward combating the issue of illegal immigration.

Both Griffin and Alvarez expressed their desire to provide tax incentives to attract high-tech industry, and Griffin said Arizona's tax structure must be reviewed to ensure it remains competitive with those of nearby states.

Alvarez said the state needs to stop focusing solely on short-term cuts to fill in budget shortfalls and must shift its energy toward securing new revenue streams.

Griffin counters that Arizona needs to curb state spending to balance the budget. According to Griffin, the state's general-fund budget has grown by $5.2 billion since she left the House.

She says she believes "less government, lower taxes, personal responsibility and the free enterprise system" to be part of the solution to what ails the state.

Alvarez, too, has said that the state has a tendency to "micromanage" some tasks better left to cities and counties. Specifically, he said, the state needs to grant more autonomy to local school districts in order to address falling standards.

Both candidates have acknowledged some of the difficulty of representing the diverse district.

And both cited their legislative experience as assets in dealing with issues, adding that working in a bipartisan way is a necessity in order to address Arizona's problems.

Manuel V. "Manny" Alvarez

• Running for: State Senate District 25

• Party: Democrat

• Age: 69

• Occupation: Retired from Arizona DES

• Education: Cochise College

• Past elected public Offices: Arizona House of Representatives 2003-2008; Senate 2009-present

• Civic activities: Health clinic, Veterans of Foreign Wars and American Legion

• Top endorsements: Public service associations, unions and health groups

• Top priority: Budget,education, health, public safety and border security

• Web address: None provided

Gail Griffin

• Running for: State Senate District 25

• Party: Republican

• Age: Not available

• Occupation: Real estate broker

• Education: Not available

• Past elected public offices: Arizona House of Representatives 1997-2000

• Civic activities: Executive board member, Project CENTRL Rural Leadership Program; member, Arizona and national associations of Realtors

• Top endorsements: National Federation of Independent Businesses, Arizona Chamber of Commerce and Industry

• Top priority: Secure the border, protect jobs and economic stability of communities

• Web address: www.gail griffin4senate.com

Luke Money is a University of Arizona journalism student apprenticing at the Star. Contact him at 573-4142 or starapprentice@azstarnet.com

Related to this collection

Today's Election Day: Here is the info

Today is Election Day. Here's what you need to know.

Arizona Daily Star
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Bluesky
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Arizona Daily Star Store
  • This is Tucson
  • Saddlebag Notes
  • Tucson Festival of Books
Prefer us on Google

Sites & Partners

  • E-edition
  • Classifieds
  • Events calendar
  • Careers @ Lee Enterprises
  • Careers @ USA Today Co.
  • Online Features
  • Sponsored Blogs
  • Get Healthy

Services

  • Advertise with us
  • Register
  • Contact us
  • RSS feeds
  • Newsletters
  • Photo reprints
  • Subscriber services
  • Subscription FAQ
  • Licensing
  • Shopping
© Copyright 2026 Arizona Daily Star, PO Box 26887 Tucson, AZ 85726-6887
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Advertising Terms of Use | Do Not Sell My Info | Cookie Preferences
Powered by BLOX Content Management System from bloxdigital.com.
  • Notifications
  • Settings
You don't have any notifications.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.

Topics

News Alerts

Breaking News