Skip to main contentSkip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
editor's pick

LD 21 Opinion: Why Hispanic activists are criticizing Biden’s FCC pick

  • Updated

The following is the opinion and analysis of the writer. Hernandez is a candidate for the Arizona House of Representatives in Legislative District 21:

Minority-owned TV networks have had to claw and scrape for years to earn a place in cable and satellite channel lineups, overcoming obstacles — including unhelpful government agencies — at every turn.

Contrast this long struggle with the red carpet rolled out for the fringe right-wing disinformation network One America News (OANN), which AT&T and DirectTV helped launch by providing a reported $57 million in funding. Even after OANN became a cesspool of race-baiting division, Big Lie sedition and COVID-19 misinformation, it took a full-scale campaign from LULAC and other civil rights advocates to finally convince DirectTV to change its mind and drop the network.

But this double-standard between the struggles faced by diverse media outlets and the door held open for right-wing propaganda networks didn’t end with DirecTV’s welcome change of heart. In fact, the same story is now playing out in a contentious fight to fill the final open seat at the Federal Communications Commission (FCC).

Gigi Sohn, President Joe Biden’s nominee to fill the pivotal role and break the commission’s current 2-2 partisan deadlock, has a deeply problematic track record on media diversity issues. As a senior staffer at the FCC in 2016, she masterminded a plan to give Google a government permission slip to steal, repackage and monetize TV programming without paying one cent to its creators.

Diverse creators screamed in opposition, with the strong support of civil rights leaders, creative industry unions and diverse lawmakers on Capitol Hill. But Sohn ignored these warnings entirely, pushing her own Big Tech-aligned ideological agenda over any concern for how her proposal would impact vulnerable, underrepresented communities.

It’s a troubling pattern we’ve seen throughout Sohn’s career. During an earlier debate over a proposed telecom merger, Sohn even suggested civil rights organizations weren’t entitled to voice their own opinions on such issues because, in her words, they are “not in the core expertise or core goals” of our movement.

But Sohn sings a very different tune when it comes to helping fringe right-wing extremists like OANN gain entry to the nation’s living rooms. OANN’s president strongly endorsed her nomination in November, praising her as an ally who had helped his network gain wider distribution. And rather than recoil in disgust and reject his support, Sohn openly bragged about it at her first confirmation hearing, gushing about how “proud” she was to have “worked with them for years to get access to cable subscribers after operators refuse to carry them.”

It’s galling to hear an advocate who has steamrolled civil rights voices and diverse creators for years now brag about helping “Donald Trump’s favorite TV network” get a wider audience. But it’s particularly jarring to hear this double-standard from a self-described progressive who is Biden’s handpicked choice to swing the balance of power on a deadlocked FCC.

This concern only grows in light of Sohn’s admission that she won’t be eligible to participate in any FCC matters relating to broadcasting retransmission or copyright. While Sohn has tried to minimize this recusal as “extremely narrow,” it effectively means she couldn’t be a champion for minority-owned broadcasters even if she wanted to.

Small, independent broadcasters locked in retransmission disputes with massively large cable and satellite companies will get no help from Sohn — or by extension, from the deadlocked FCC her recusal would produce.

I’m at a loss to understand why Democrats are risking such a critically important nomination on such a flawed candidate.

Biden should withdraw this nomination and consider other options. In particular, he should consider nominating one of the many highly-qualified, experienced and capable Hispanic telecommunications experts that the White House ignored in its initial consideration.

Representation matters — both on TV, and at the agencies that regulate it.

Consuelo Hernandez is the secretary of the League of United Latin American Citizens Council #1209 and president of the Sunnyside Unified School District Governing Board. She lives in Tucson. She is a candidate for the Arizona House of Representatives in Legislative District 21.

Subscribe to stay connected to Tucson. A subscription helps you access more of the local stories that keep you connected to the community.

Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

OPINION: "For an example of staggering hypocrisy and potential karma, consider Merrick Garland. He was nominated by Barack Obama in March 2016 for a Supreme Court position, seven months before the election. Mitch McConnell decided to not give Garland a hearing. Why? 2016 was an election year," writes Green Valley resident Paul McCreary. 

OPINION: "So there you have it: two potential future second terms, a study in contrast. One potential path for our nation is the quiet, patient and highly effective competence which for the first part of the Biden administration has put America back on track. The second is the chaos, scandal and division of a restored Donald Trump eager to roll back gains for working people and turn our civilian military into his personal junta," writes Star contributor Terry Bracy. 

OPINION: "Today, I find myself wondering just how many of us would be willing to undergo and tolerate the inequities and dishonor that that woman had to suffer in order to have the right to vote," writes Tucsonan Robert Nordmeyer

OPINION: "If the American people knew the facts regarding the political football game that takes place along the southern border line of scrimmage during election cycles, then maybe the narrative would be elevated to a debate on the reality of the situation, and perhaps a concerted effort could be made to do something proactive to deal with human migration," writes Myles Traphagen, borderlands program coordinator for Wildlands Network in Tucson

OPINION: "Here is where the rubber hits the road locally. His big lie has hoodwinked Arizona’s Goldwater Republicans. Now, he demands everyone take a loyalty oath to his person — not the Constitution," writes Tucsonan Kenneth Mowbray. 

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News