LAS VEGAS — A grand jury in Nevada again indicted Nathan Chasing Horse on charges that he sexually abused Indigenous women and girls for decades, reviving a sweeping criminal case against the former "Dances with Wolves" actor.
The 21-count indictment unsealed Thursday in Clark County District Court expands on the 48-year-old's previous felony charges of sexual assault, lewdness and kidnapping to also include charges of producing and possessing child sexual abuse materials.
The move came after the Nevada Supreme Court in September ordered the dismissal of Chasing Horse's original 18-count indictment, while leaving open the possibility for charges to be refiled. Proceedings in the case had been at a standstill for more than a year while Chasing Horse challenged it.
People are also reading…
The court sided with Chasing Horse, saying in its scathing order that prosecutors abused the grand jury process.
Clark County District Attorney Steve Wolfson quickly vowed to seek another indictment. Neither Wolfson nor a spokesperson for his office immediately responded Thursday to phone or emailed requests for comment.
Best known for portraying the character Smiles A Lot in the 1990 movie "Dances with Wolves," Chasing Horse was born on the Rosebud Reservation in South Dakota, which is home to the Sicangu Sioux, one of the seven tribes of the Lakota nation.
After starring in the Oscar-winning film, authorities say, he propped himself up as a self-proclaimed Lakota medicine man while traveling around North America to perform healing ceremonies.
Nathan Chasing Horse sits April 3, 2023, in Las Vegas court.
Prosecutors said his position in the community granted him access to vulnerable women and girls for decades until his arrest last January near Las Vegas. He has been jailed ever since.
Chasing Horse's arrest reverberated around Indian Country. Law enforcement in the U.S. and Canada quickly followed up with more criminal charges, saying his arrest helped corroborate long-standing allegations against him, including on the Fort Peck Indian Reservation in Montana where tribal leaders banished Chasing Horse in 2015 amid allegations of human trafficking.
Authorities in Alberta, Canada, acknowledged their case is largely symbolic. Chasing Horse — who faces decades in a Nevada prison if convicted — might not ever return to Canada.
“At the end of the day,” Sgt. Nancy Farmer of the Tsuut’ina Nation Police Service said, “it is important for us to have these warrants in the system so our victims know they’ve been heard. It’s extremely important that we continue to support them that way.”
Police described Chasing Horse as a a cull leader who took underage wives. In Las Vegas, he pleaded not guilty to the original charges.
His new lawyer didn't immediately respond to an email seeking comment, and his former public defender, Kristy Holston, said she had no comment on the new indictment.
The latest indictment also accuses Chasing Horse of filming himself having sex with one of his accusers when she was younger than 14. Prosecutors say the footage, taken in 2010 or 2011, was found on cellphones in a locked safe inside the North Las Vegas home that Chasing Horse is said to have shared with five wives, including the girl in the videos.
When the Nevada Supreme Court ordered the dismissal of Chasing Horse's initial indictment, the judges said they were not weighing in on his guilt or innocence, calling the allegations against him serious. But the court said prosecutors improperly provided the grand jury with a definition of grooming without expert testimony, and faulted them for withholding from the grand jury inconsistent statements made by one of his accusers.
Chasing Horse's legal issues are unfolding at the same time lawmakers and prosecutors around the U.S. are funneling more resources into cases involving Native women, including human trafficking and murders.
Native voters could swing US elections, but they're asking politicians: What have you done for us?
Navajo horsewomen circle pass a volleyball Oct. 18 during the Western Navajo Fair in Tuba City, Ariz. Natives, which make up 5.2% of the state’s population, voted in big numbers for the Democratic party in 2020 and were credited with swinging the state blue for the first time in decades.
A Navajo horsewoman carries a U.S. flag as she waits for the start of the Western Navajo Fair opening ceremony Oct. 18 in Tuba City, Ariz. Native people were first recognized as U.S. citizens 100 years ago, but Arizona prevented them from exercising their right to vote until 1948.
Navajo Trump supporters eat dinner Oct. 10 during a meeting at Freedom House on the Navajo Nation in Window Rock, Ariz. In the lead up to U.S. elections in November, Democrats and Republicans flocked the furthest reaches of 22 Native American reservations in Arizona in a bid to court their votes.
Campaign posters promoting candidates competing in the November general election are displayed Oct. 11 on a wire fence outside a gas station on the Navajo Nation in Window Rock, Ariz.
A monument to the Navajo Code Talkers of World War II stands Oct. 10 in front of the red sandstone arch of Window Rock, Ariz., outside the Navajo Nation government headquarters. Native voters could swing U.S. elections, but they're asking politicians: What have you done for us?
Storm clouds form Oct. 18 over Highway 264 on the Navajo Nation outside Tuba City, Ariz. Soaring unemployment and poverty pushed young Navajos to leave their sacred lands in search of jobs.
Navajo Felix Ashley checks his post office box Oct. 16 on the Navajo Nation in Dilkon, Arizona. This year, Native voters have turned into a powerful electoral force. But those same voters have long lacked basic things like running water and jobs on reservations, and have historically faced massive logistical barriers and voter suppression standing in their way of voting.
Navajo Felix Ashley prepares Oct. 16 to transfer water, which he collected from a pump miles away, outside his home on the Navajo Nation in Dilkon, Ariz. Nearly a third of Navajo Nation's homes like Ashley's don't have running water.
Navajo Francine Bradley-Arthur poses for a photo Oct. 11 in front of Freedom House, a grassroots pro-Trump campaign house she founded, on the Navajo Nation in Window Rock, Ariz. The former Democrat said she began to campaign for Donald Trump, in part, because she felt Native communities often didn’t feel the payoff of longtime support for Democrats.
Navajo goat herder Richard Begay places his gun in his holster Oct. 17 as he prepares for his day on the Navajo Nation in Dilkon, Ariz. He is up at 6 a.m. sharp to flip on conservative radio and sip coffee out of a mug reading "TRUMP. Best President Ever."
Navajo goat herder Richard Begay works on his computer Oct. 17 inside his home on the Navajo Nation in Dilkon, Ariz.
Navajo Richard Begay poses for a portrait Oct. 17 while taking a break from herding his goats on the Navajo Nation in Dilkon, Ariz.
Navajo Richard Begay herds his goats Oct. 17 on the Navajo Nation in Dilkon, Ariz.
Navajo cowboys compete in a rodeo event Oct. 18 during the Western Navajo Fair in Tuba City, Ariz.
Navajos gather for a "Get out the vote" march Oct. 12 on the Navajo Nation in Fort Defiance, Ariz., in a push for Native Americans to vote in the Nov. 5 presidential election. Logistical and legal obstacles long stood in the way of Arizona's 420,000 Native citizens casting their vote.
A Navajo woman waves Oct. 19 as she campaigns for presidential hopeful Kamala Harris in a caravan of Democratic-themed floats at the Western Navajo Fair in Tuba City, Ariz.
Navajo couples parade past in their traditional dress to compete in a dance contest Oct. 19 at the Western Navajo Fair in Tuba City, Ariz.
First-time voters gather at an Oct. 12 "Get out the vote" goat-roping event on the Navajo Nation in Blue Gap, Ariz.
Democratic Senate candidate Ruben Gallego treks through the Havasu Canyon on Oct. 14 hoping to meet with members of the Havasupai tribe, on the outskirts of Supai, Ariz.
Young Havasupai dancers prepare Oct. 14 to perform a traditional dance welcoming Democratic Senate candidate Ruben Gallego in Supai, Ariz. Gallego hoped to connect with voters in the Havasupai reservation, which has only 156 registered voters, to fulfill a campaign pledge to visit all the Native American tribes in Arizona.
A woman chooses campaign posters Oct. 12 during a "Get out the vote" event on Navajo Nation in Fort Defiance, Ariz.
Navajo Kathleen Begay places a crown on her daughter Oct. 12 as they prepare to take part in a "Get out the vote" march on the Navajo Nation in Fort Defiance, Ariz.
Ceremonial dancers wait to perform Oct. 12 at a "Get out the vote" event on Navajo Nation in Fort Defiance, Ariz., in a push for Native Americans to vote in the Nov. 5 presidential election.
Buckets of water to use for flushing are stored Oct. 15 in the bathroom of Hopi Rosalie Talahongva in Mishongnovi, Ariz.
Hopi Rosalie Talahongva and husband Mervin Yoyetewa load firewood into the bed of their truck Oct. 15 in Flagstaff, Ariz.
Local organizer Maria Calamity instructs a resident Oct. 11 on how to properly fill out a pledge card promising to vote in the Nov. 5 presidential election, on the Navajo Nation in Ganado, Ariz.
Havasupai tribal leaders Matthew Putesoy, left, and Thaddeus Wescogame, prepare to perform a ceremonial dance Oct. 14 during the visit of Democratic Senate candidate Ruben Gallego in Supai, Ariz.
Democratic Senate candidate Ruben Gallego meets with Havasupai tribal leaders Oct. 14 in Supai, Ariz. The tribe is so rural, election authorities helicopter ballots and election supplies in and out of the canyon.
