Bad stats: 7/10
Role in team success: 7/10
Expectations: 6/10
Overall Bust Index: 20/30
In four years at Florida, Tebow enjoyed one of the most decorated careers in college football history. During his four years in The Swamp, the Gators won two national championships and three BCS bowl games. Tebow threw for 9,285 yards and rushed for 2,947 for his career, with 145 total touchdowns.
After his college career ended, Tebow was among the most polarizing players of the 2010 draft. His unorthodox throwing motion and muscular build — uncharacteristic of prototypical NFL quarterbacks — made many skeptical. The Broncos drafted him with the No. 25 pick, and in 2011 he posted a 7-4 record as a starter, helping lead the team to a playoff win over the Steelers. Even with his team's success, Tebow struggled as a passer, completing just 46.5 percent of his throws that season. His career deteriorated pretty quickly after that, which lands him on this list, but he'll always be a part of one of the most memorable plays in NFL playoff history.
