It turns out that attorneys have almost as much difficulty getting CPS records in child abuse cases as the media does.
Last month, Ashley Kammerer's defense attorney, Dawn Priestman, asked Judge Richard Fields for unredacted CPS reports pertaining to her client because the reports she had were so blacked out she couldn't make heads or tails out of them.
Judge Fields had a hearing on the issue and he ordered CPS to provide the records to him with a detailed list of what the agency's attorneys wanted blacked out and why.
He also directed Priestman to give him a detailed list of what she hoped to "gleam" from the reports. Once he sees both he'll decide what, if anything, Priestman is entitled to.
Her memo to the judge provides a lot of info that hasn't been reported before.
People are also reading…
First, a recap:Â
Back in January we reported Kammerer, 23, was arrested on suspicion of felony child abuse. Tucson police told us that staff at a local hospital contacted them because her then 22-month-old son only weighed 14 pounds.
Investigators determined the boy suffered from medical conditions that required special feeding and they believed Kammerer wasn't providing him the necessary care. They said his weight nearly doubled once he was taken away from Kammerer and given to CPS.
According to Priestman's memo:
* Kammerer has four children between the ages of 1 and 5.
* Kammerer's 3-year-old son suffers from a congenital defect that requires him to be fed through a feeding tube attached to his stomach.
* The boy spent the first seven months of his life at UMC undergoing treatment and surgeries.
* Kammerer took the boy to the hospital or doctors more than 30 times between June 2010 and July 2011.
* She was arrested after she took the child to the doctor because he'd lost six pounds between July 2011 and September 2011.
* Prosecutors want jurors to know that CPS got involved with the family in August 2008 because her oldest boy lost a lot of weight when he was about nine-months-old. That child now lives with his father.
Priestman wants all of the CPS records to find out, among other things, who didn't like her client and who was talking to CPS about her alleged mistreatment of the children.
"Ms. Kammerer is a young woman with no criminal history," Priestman wrote in her memo. "She is going to trial on an offense which carries a penalty of 10 to 24 years in prison. She has a substantial need for all the requested information as a basic evidentiary need or as an investigative lead."
Naturally, CPS' memo to the judge will never see the light of day.
Â

