You would think Karl Simmeth would be busy this week. After all, the Republican National Convention kicks off on Monday, and Simmeth, the Erie County Republican chairman, is a delegate.
But this is a convention where the delegate's responsibilities are, well, delegated. Simmeth, like many of the 2,550 delegates, will be voting by proxy Monday morning as about 300 party leaders from across the country gather in Charlotte to renominate Donald Trump for a second term in the White House.
Erie County Republican Chair Karl J. Simmeth Jr. (Harry Scull Jr./Buffalo News)
With the pandemic limiting in-person attendance, the convention will be as much of a television show for Simmeth and most of the delegates as it will be for the millions who will be watching on the networks or online.
"To be there, I thought it would be the experience of a lifetime," Simmeth said. "But then it all comes crashing down, so what are you going to do?"
People are also reading…
The Covid-19 pandemic left both political parties to conclude that it wouldn't be a great idea to draw thousands of delegates into crowded arenas where they would shout and scream and cheer at the top of their lungs.
So this week's Republican National Convention will be a largely virtual affair. But unlike the Democrats' virtual gathering – which came with an agenda – the GOP convention is still pretty much an enigma .
The gathering's nighttime show will run from 8:30 to 11 p.m. Monday through Thursday, a half-hour longer than what the Democrats did. But as of Friday afternoon, the Republicans had released little information about the convention schedule.
Pressed for details by Fox News last week, Ronna McDaniel, who chairs the Republican National Committee, offered few clues.
"There will be live programming every night. The keynote speakers will all be live," she said. "And then some of it, we're going to just have to let you see. There's going to be some surprises."
The show
Republican leaders are confident that their convention organizers will put on an entertaining program.
"I know our president loves showmanship, so I expect we’ll have a better lineup than the Democrats,” said state Republican Chairman Nicholas A. Langworthy, the former Erie County GOP chair. “We have to try and engage as many folks as we can.”
The headline engagement, of course, will be President Trump's acceptance speech, to be broadcast from the White House South Lawn on Thursday night.
Choosing the outdoor space at the White House gives Trump the chance to stage a scaled-down version of what he always wanted: a raucous celebration of his renomination. The event, moved to the White House after the pandemic forced it out of Charlotte and then Jacksonville, Fla., will feature a live audience – including many Republican members of Congress.
Republicans expect Trump to bring a law-and-order focus to his speech, playing up recent protests in Portland, Ore., and elsewhere as something Democrats have encouraged – and that he's willing to stop it, if necessary. The Covid-19 pandemic – which has claimed about 175,000 lives nationwide – and Trump's much-criticized response to it are not expected to be major topics.
"I certainly hope that, as president, he conveys to the nation that we're going to get through this challenging time, and that he also reminds everyone of all the progress that was made in the first years of his administration in terms of tax reform and reworking bad trade deals," said Rep. Chris Jacobs of Orchard Park, who is not a delegate and who is not yet sure if he will attend the president's speech.
Jacobs also wants to see Trump tell the nation that he repaired the American economy and that its fundamentals remain strong despite the job losses stemming from the pandemic.
Beyond Trump's speech, First Lady Melania Trump will speak at the White House on Tuesday, and Vice President Mike Pence will deliver remarks Wednesday from Fort McHenry in Baltimore. Other politicians expected to speak include former UN Ambassador Nikki Haley, Rep. Elise Stefanik of New York's North Country and Sen. Tim Scott of South Carolina.
But, like the Democrats, Republicans are expected to emphasize an unusual number of non-politicians in the program.
"I think probably the biggest thing is the untold stories that will be told next week," White House chief of staff Mark Meadows told reporters last Tuesday. "I think that will be the biggest surprises."
Word of some of the surprise speakers has already leaked out. Among them: Patricia and Mark McCloskey, the St. Louis couple who famously brandished firearms when Black Lives Matter protesters appeared on their street earlier this summer, and Nicholas Sandmann, the Ohio teen involved in a videotaped encounter with a Native American leader that went viral during the 2019 March for Life.
Such appearances seem geared to energizing Trump's conservative base at a time when polls show him several points behind former Vice President Joe Biden, the Democratic presidential nominee. And overall, McDaniel said, the convention will show that the Republican Party is in touch with a wide swath of average Americans.
"The Democrats have started every night with a Hollywood actress 'elite-'splaining' to America what the coasts and the elite and the big tech and Hollywood individuals think about how we should view America," she said on Fox News. "The president's convention is going to be about real people."
What's missing
Whatever the Republicans' prime time show looks like, it won't be about the nuts-and-bolts business of politics. What little of that there is will be happening as soon as the convention officially opens at 9 a.m. Monday, when those party leaders – including Langworthy – gather in a Charlotte ballroom for the roll call vote to renominate Trump.
Another one of that GOP conclave’s few attendees will be Charles P. Joyce of Wellsville, the oilfield equipment dealer who is a major Republican donor and one of New York State’s two members of the Republican National Committee. He said he will miss the “fanfare and the frivolity” of a typical convention.
This convention will also be absent something that New York Democrats maintained via Zoom last week: the delegation breakfasts that give rising political stars a chance to speak and established politicos a chance to schmooze. With so little going on beyond the nighttime show, the state GOP made no plans for such events.
In other words, the traditional "delegate experience" won't happen, Langworthy said.
“I obviously share in the disappointment,” he added. “This is the Super Bowl of politics and to be a delegate is an honor.”
This year, though, it's not much of a thrill.
"The business end of it was already kind of completed when we set it in our proxies," said Niagara County GOP Chairman Richard L. Andres Jr. "That's all they want of us, I guess. So it's not super exciting."
It's not super exciting, even, for members of Congress such as Rep. Tom Reed of Corning, a delegate who will be watching from home.
"I guess it's the nature of the beast, given that Covid-19 has dictated these unusual circumstances," Reed said.
But those unusual circumstances are disappointing to many of the delegates, including Trish Turner, the Ontario County Republican chair.
She said it is "beyond sad" for her to finally become a delegate only to be stuck at home, watching the convention just like anybody else .
Turner watched the Democratic convention last week and came away less than impressed
“It felt more like an infomercial, to the point where you have to ask if it’s worth making it a publicized event," she said.
“I feel bad for both sides,” she added. “It doesn’t even feel like a convention.”

