The following is the opinion and analysis of the writer:
Gil Shapiro
In her recent Ex-etiquette column, Dr. Jann Blackstone cited the difficulty and stress for blended and extended families to manage and negotiate holiday time together.
Who will visit whom for Thanksgiving, Hanukkah, and Christmas? The planning for these gatherings can be exasperating and contentious. We often hear iterations of, “We’ll spend Thanksgiving with Dad’s (new) family(ies) and Christmas/Hanukkah with Mom’s (new) family(ies);” or perhaps, “We’ll spend the day with Dad and the evening with Mom.”
Among the biggest concerns with making these arrangements are how to best placate those who don’t get along with various family members, or how to deal with those who have travel and logistic problems.
Indeed, the holidays are not uniformly joyful for a significant percentage of our population. This gloom and angst are in large part due to our nation’s divorce rate which has been for years at about 50% for first marriages and about 60% and 73% for second and third marriages respectively.
People are also reading…
Those statistics belie the fact that many bad marriages never end in divorce. Unhappy couples remain together for myriad reasons.
And, according to multiple studies, bad relationships adversely affect one’s health — especially increasing the rate of heart attacks.
Whom we marry is arguably the most important decision we ever make. And marrying the wrong person can bring on a lifetime of lifechanging misfortunes.
I would like to propose a step that may help to reduce marriage dissolutions — and heart attacks.
But be forewarned: What I suggest may be outrageous and perhaps even unconstitutional. But please consider, as at least worthy of discussion, my very pragmatic approach to addressing this persistent and pernicious societal dilemma.
I propose states experiment, for a reasonable number of years, with requiring that prior to issuing marriage licenses, each applicant complete a computerized compatibility profile, developed and certified as valid and reliable by a consensus of state-approved marriage therapists. The goal of this evaluation would be to compile a large database to determine whether such profiles are of predictive value for determining the success or failure of marriages.
And yes, it must be a requirement. If voluntary, it will only include the cohort agreeing to the evaluation and will skew the results.
Couples, of course, could opt out of learning the results.
The reasons for good and bad marriages are many. But the proposed assessment would constitute a good faith attempt to offer the intended parties, prior to commitment, an objective third-party tool for them to better reflect on their compatibility on matters such as morals, ethics, money, career, family, and other issues deemed essential for successful long-term unions by family law attorneys and marriage therapists. If these evaluations were compelling for their predictive power, then states should seriously consider continuing to use them.
To be sure, despite results indicating high incompatibility, no couple would be denied their marriage license.
That said, it would be interesting to note how many marriages lasted or dissolved after profile results indicated major incompatibilities for those who still chose to marry.
To wit: Consider a profile reveals that “85% of couples who scored as you did divorce within five years”. That conclusion alerts the individuals that their decision to marry warrants reevaluation.
It seems illogical that the state should be completely involved with the dissolution of a marriage, yet totally indifferent to its formation. It’s ironic that requirements for marriage licensure are few, yet textbooks are written on divorce law, family counseling, domestic violence, traumatized children, and how these conflicts undermine the fabric of our society.
Indeed, if a state succeeds in this endeavor, it will save considerable time, effort and money in dealing with the disastrous consequences of predictably ill-fated unions. The benefits of fewer divorces will also mean fewer broken homes, failed careers, depressions and bankruptcies.
Many will emphatically assert that the state has no business interfering with its citizens’ love lives. They will claim this intrusion is a major unjustified government overreach; and maybe unconstitutional as well. But why shouldn’t the government take a major step to lessen the far-reaching destructive ramifications of bad marriages? States mandate seatbelts, a legal drinking age, and a minimum voting age. Why would this equally beneficial mandate be too unreasonable?
As love relationships evolve and deepen, it is human nature for many couples to ignore or defer resolving important yet potentially confrontational and ultimately irreconcilable issues. They fear, of course, that such discussions will take the wind out of their romantic sails. They blissfully (and wrongly, of course) think that differences in how each partner deals with money, career, children or conflicting visions of their future will magically resolve during their marriage. At their peril, they also ignore the reality that their legal, business, and in many cases parental and family responsibilities, will continue after their divorce.
Marriage is both a love and “business” relationship. For romance and enterprise to succeed, there must be harmony between heart and head. The state, in the way I proposed, should consider playing its part.
Follow these steps to easily submit a letter to the editor or guest opinion to the Arizona Daily Star.
Gil Shapiro lives in Oro Valley. He was the spokesperson for Freethought Arizona from 2005 to 2016. Contact him at: gdshapiro@comcast.net

