On Friday, the Francis Howell School Board did the St. Louis region a kind of backward favor.
After deciding in a cowardly closed session the night before how it would deal with transfer students from the Normandy Schools Collaborative in the upcoming school year, the board of the mostly white district announced it was closing its doors to mostly poor, black transfer students from north St. Louis County.
Never mind that about 350 students who were bused to Francis Howell in the most recent school year wanted to come back. Never mind that the school board pocketed about $1 million in profit last year while the Normandy district went bankrupt.
Go home, the Francis Howell board said. We don’t want you.
What a shameful example for the entire region, for superintendents and school boards, kids and parents. The Francis Howell board showed us the worst of ourselves.
People are also reading…
It’s not too late to change your minds. Please do the exact opposite. Choose unity over division. Choose education over profit. Choose right over wrong.
Ever since the Missouri Supreme Court ruled a year ago that children of unaccredited schools could transfer at no cost to their parents to a better school in an adjacent district or county, lawmakers, government officials, unions, reformers and political activists have been engaged in a game of picking winners and losers.
In that long, painful process, about the only thing that all sides could agree on is that every solution is good for somebody at the expense of somebody else. That is true of the proponents of more choice in public schools. It’s true of the teachers’ unions. It’s true of suburban superintendents and their school boards. It’s true of this editorial page. Every single solution proposed to provide better education opportunity for the children of Normandy and Riverview Gardens, and other districts that might become unaccredited and face the reality of the transfer crisis, is fraught with peril for some families and full of hope for others.
The challenge has been to find that balance, that common ground, that produces the most good for the greatest number, with the primary focus being on improving educational opportunity for kids who have had to wait entirely too long for it.
After a series of actions proposed this month by Education Commissioner Chris Nicastro and adopted by the state Board of Education, there might be light at the end of the tunnel. At least, that’s what we thought before the callous decision by the Francis Howell board.
There are no guarantees that the new path the state is blazing, much of which is outside existing state law, is going to work. Some of the board’s proposals are downright heartbreaking.
But the Board of Education has proposed the three things that have the most potential for breaking the stalemate that led to legislative failure each of the past three years.
• It has adopted a budget for the new Normandy Schools Collaborative that should maintain that district’s solvency. It should allow it to build on some of the gains it made last year amid the chaos. It can do this even as the state considers changes to curriculum, longer school years, and an influx of new teachers and principals.
• It tried to maintain the ability for most — not all — of the students who previously transferred to suburban districts to stay at their new schools if their parents choose that. Normandy would still have had to pay transportation costs to and from the Francis Howell schools, but the Francis Howell board doesn’t want to play.
• The board set tuition for transfer students at about $7,200, the same amount those districts accept for St. Louis city students who attend under the voluntary choice program. No more profiteering by the suburban districts.
Most superintendents have agreed to play by the new rules. The Francis Howell board, along with other school boards in the St. Louis region, should adopt this as the best possible solution for this year. It would maintain a fair financial balance, while giving those thousands of students in Normandy and Riverview Gardens the opportunity along with their teachers, parents and administrators to turn things around.
Even before the disgraceful decision by the Francis Howell board, this wasn’t going to be easy. The struggle facing urban school districts stuck in geographic areas awash with poverty is massive.
However, the unprecedented attention focused on the problem in St. Louis over the past couple of years offers a glimmer of hope. Normandy in particular has developed partnerships with Beyond Housing, with the business community, with the University of Missouri-St. Louis, that at least promote a civic understanding that this is a problem for the entire region to solve.
St. Louis, as a region, should take responsibility for all of its children. Suburban districts should offer charters in the city schools. The districts should erase their borders and become one district, as a state commission first proposed in 1968. This is about unity, about moving all of St. Louis in the right direction.
Here’s one way to get there: Suburban school boards must do the exact opposite of what Francis Howell did. Become part of the solution, not part of the problem. Accept the transfer students and the lower tuition amount.
They’ve done it before. Much like with the creation of the voluntary transfer program implemented in 1981, they have to think of the much more drastic consequences if they don’t act in unity: At some point the federal courts are not going to allow yet further generations of minority students to be lost.
The federal government will step in. The consequences could be severe.
Frankly, the failure of the community to act in the best interests of all of its children has already had severe consequences. It’s time to reverse that trend.
The state Board of Education should use whatever powers it can muster to make sure that every child who previously transferred still can do so next year. The board should work with charter-school organizers to bring a proven charter model to Normandy. The Legislature should realize the opportunity it has before it and give Normandy the money it needs to provide the extra services necessary for children in poverty to learn, including providing universal preschool.
Every suburban school district should offer one of its best and brightest — a teacher, an administrator, a curriculum specialist — on loan for one year to Normandy or Riverview Gardens. The surest way to reduce the number of transfers is to improve the schools in the communities where the children live.
We wanted to be hopeful today. We didn’t want to criticize anybody. The first draft of this editorial was written before Francis Howell’s leaders gave us no choice. The task now, with start of the 2014-15 school year mere weeks away, is finding a way to come together, to be one St. Louis.
We can all root for the Cardinals. Why can’t we all root for all of our kids?

