Through 10 weeks, the 2026 NFL Draft class only has a select few players taking on starring roles right away.
The latest crop of rookies features plenty of success stories, as well as some early letdowns. For all the promise shown thus far, however, only a handful of top picks — such as New York Giants linebacker Arvell Reese, New York Jets edge rusher David Bailey, Kansas City Chiefs cornerback Mansoor Delane and Washington Commanders linebacker Sonny Styles — have risen to the level of top performers regardless of experience level.
Still, several players taken on Day 2 or 3 deserve the midseason spotlight after turning heads with their initial contributions.
Here are nine rookies who are off to surprising starts so far this fall: ( All stats through Week 10)
Emmett Johnson
People are also reading…
Kansas City Chiefs running back Emmett Johnson, right, celebrates with quarterback Patrick Mahomes after scoring a touchdown during the fourth quarter against the Atlanta Falcons at Mercedes-Benz Stadium on Nov. 15 in Atlanta.
Emmett Johnson, a fifth-round pick from Nebraska, has served as a fascinating case study in weighing instincts against athleticism at running back. An All-American at Nebraska, Johnson saw his star fade a bit during the pre-draft process as more physically gifted ball carriers stepped into the spotlight.
As Kenneth Walker III's backup in Kansas City, however, he's quickly reinforced his value. But with the highly priced free agent signing sidelined by a groin injury, Johnson delivered his most meaningful outing to date by recording 171 yards from scrimmage on 28 touches in a 35-13 win over the Atlanta Falcons.
Johnson hasn't merely benefitted from what's been blocked for him, as his 45.6% rate of forcing at least one missed tackle is the best in the NFL among players with at least 50 touches, according to Next Gen Stats. That slipperiness and reliability as a receiver — he has caught 20 of 23 targets for 307 yards — have made him indispensable to a Kansas City offense that hasn't been able to count on igniting big plays downfield after its hot start. Fold in his solid contributions as a kick returner (318 yards on 11 returns), and the Chiefs should be thrilled with its budget backup.
Kaelon Black
Selecting Kaelon Black, a non-combine invitee, in the third round ahead of some more highly regarded options earned San Francisco a good bit of scrutiny on draft day. So far, though, a franchise that's had a spotty record of identifying mid-round running backs is faring well with its latest complement for Christian McCaffrey.
Black is already up to 356 yards and two rushing touchdowns on 79 carries. Known for his hard-charging style, the former Indiana standout has seen more than 82% of his production (295 yards) come after contact. With three consecutive games of at least 11 carries, his workload should remain steady for a team that surely would like to avoid overexerting McCaffrey down the stretch.
Jonah Coleman
Denver Broncos running back Jonah Coleman celebrates after scoring a touchdown against the Carolina Panthers during the second half at Bank of America Stadium on Nov. 8 in Charlotte, N.C.
When Sean Payton praises a rookie, it's worth paying attention to the Denver Broncos coach, who is famously stingy in handing out reps to first-year players. In late October, however, Payton declared his interest in finding more touches for the fourth-rounder. It has since become even more apparent why he was seeking a change of pace.
Payton's statement came after Jonah Coleman, who missed the previous four games due to a high ankle sprain, had 69 yards on 11 touches against the Arizona Cardinals. In the two games after that, the Washington product notched 192 yards from scrimmage. Having that kind of consistency on early downs — and some semblance of a big-play threat — has made a substantial difference for an offense that ranks 31st in third-down conversion percentage. With Coleman keeping the attack on schedule more easily than J.K. Dobbins has, Denver has more frequently avoided the obvious passing situations that have proved so daunting.
Utilizing a bell-cow back has never been Payton's way. For a team that has grown accustomed to persevering in close contests and has had to count on efficiency, though, Coleman seems like the clear lead option the rest of the way.
Caleb Douglas
Thrust into a starting role for a team with no clear-cut weapons, Caleb Douglas had every excuse this season to post limited returns. Yet for all the roadblocks the Miami Dolphins' offense has put up, the third-round pick has delivered as an efficient downfield threat.
Though he missed three early games with an ankle injury, his 61.2 yards per game is tops among all rookies. He's still been responsible for a good number of miscues, but Miami's season has largely been defined by a trial-and-error approach anyway. With the Dolphins' future at quarterback unsettled, the emergence of a 6-foot-4 target who averages 16.7 yards per catch should help first-year coach Jeff Hafley feel more at ease about where the offense is headed.
Denzel Boston
Cleveland Browns wide receiver Denzel Boston warms up prior to a game against the Pittsburgh Steelers at Acrisure Stadium on Nov. 1 in Pittsburgh.
As the No. 39 overall pick on a team with a dearth of competition at receiver, Denzel Boston looked poised to have a big role out of the gates for the Cleveland Browns. Still, in propping up Cleveland's passing attack, the well-built wideout might have pushed his way to the front of the race for Offensive Rookie of the Year.
Boston led all 2026 draft picks with 523 receiving yards at the midway point of the season. Establishing a downfield connection with Deshaun Watson hasn't been easy, as his 33 catches on 62 targets have reflected. But in repeatedly beating man coverage and skying for contested catches, the 6-foot-4, 215-pound target has erased all pre-draft concerns about his viability as a vertical threat.
Josiah Trotter
Todd Bowles' defense repeatedly came apart at the second level last season. Between that glaring vulnerability and the retirement of franchise fixture Lavonte David, Tampa Bay seemed due for a new day at linebacker. Through the first half of the season, Josiah Trotter has outpaced even the most optimistic projections of his play.
Operating downhill has never been a problem for the son of three-time Pro Bowl selection Jeremiah Trotter. With the Buccaneers, the younger Trotter has continued to throttle opposing rushing attacks. His greatest strides, however, have come in coverage, with his Week 1 pick-six of Joe Burrow foreshadowing his growth. That might never be his strong suit, but so long as he can at least hold his own against backs and tight ends, he could end up being a far more versatile defensive piece than many envisioned him as after his career at Missouri.
Gabe Jacas
New England Patriots linebacker Gabe Jacas celebrates a missed field goal by the Chicago Bears during the second half at Soldier Field on Oct. 22 in Chicago.
It's not easy to find bright spots on a New England Patriots defense that conceded 80 points over Week 9 and 10. But outside linebacker Gabe Jacas, the second-round pick from Illinois, surely qualifies as one.
At 6-foot-4 and 260 pounds, the former high school wrestling champion has been extremely difficult for opposing blockers to pin down. His ultraphysical and unrelenting approach to pass rushing has yielded 3 1/2 sacks and 25 pressures through Week 10. He's also been a steady presence against the run. Jacas' efforts haven't been enough to vault a unit that continues to settle in the middle of the pack in creating havoc for opposing quarterbacks, but he's entrenched himself as an asset on the edge for years to come.
Zakee Wheatley
Injuries at cornerback ravaged Carolina's secondary, thereby shutting down any shot the unit had of achieving a long-awaited breakthrough. But don't blame Zakee Wheatley, the fifth-round safety out of Penn State who's done more than anyone could have expected in the early going.
After being a healthy scratch in the season opener, Wheatley acquitted himself nicely while steadily becoming a key piece on the back end of the Panthers' defense. With Todd Wash taking over for the ousted Ejiro Evero as interim defensive coordinator, the rookie now figures to be entrusted with even more after he got his first start and played in 100% of the defensive snaps against the New Orleans Saints. Limited ball production (one interception and four passes defensed) might deprive him of wider acclaim. But Carolina needs someone it can count on to make the right decisions in coverage and as a run stopper, and Wheatley's acumen on both fronts is serving him and the Panthers well.
Brandon Cisse
Green Bay Packers cornerback Brandon Cisse reacts to a call during the third quarter against the Detroit Lions at Ford Field on Oct. 25 in Detroit.
Fourth-round edge rusher Dani Dennis-Sutton warranted mention on this list, thanks in large part to an astronomical 18.2% pressure rate that stacks up with many of the league's best. Yet the Penn State product has stood out as a sub-package sparkplug, whereas cornerback Brandon Cisse has held his own as a Day 1 starter with the Green Bay Packers.
The second-round pick from South Carolina was peppered with questions throughout the pre-draft process of whether he was properly prepared to be a consistent coverage presence. In Green Bay, however, he's shown himself to be a quick study after bouncing back from giving up a touchdown in each of his first two games. He earned Defensive Rookie of the Month for October after recording a sack, an interception and seven passes defensed in five games during that span. A rib injury knocked him out early in the loss to the Minnesota Vikings, but Cisse should be back in the fold quickly as part of one of the league's best playmaking secondaries.
Come fall, draft status carries only so much cachet in the NFL.

