Today’s queries are from readers who need to downsize. Each wonders what specific items are worth because their goal is to sell.
We get a lot of inquiries about selling off long-time treasures, and I can tell you this: The decision to begin downsizing is the easiest part of the process. Tough choices follow.
Paring down can be a tough proposition, but one many collectors face sooner or later. The trap lies in making hasty decisions without an informed base. Read and learn.
Reader No. 1 sent photos of items that illustrate our point.
First is a mass-produced rocking chair from the first quarter of the 20th century. It has open wooden arms and a wood frame that looks to be oak. The back and seat are reupholstered in plush. Original covering was probably leather or horsehide.
People are also reading…
The other item is a simple walnut 4-legged table with two drop leaves.
Both pieces look in top condition, but the rocker is a genre that’s a tough sell today. The advent of recliners in many forms has made the rocker, a staple of earlier eras, a curiosity. Rockers are heavy and bulky and, let’s face it, often not that comfortable.
I’m advising the reader to keyliveauctioneers.com for a look at auction results for similar chairs. When we looked, most similar rockers sold for $35-$100 online or at auction.
The potential buyer for this hybrid rocker combining an old frame with contemporary plush is going to be someone who accepts lack of purity in design.
The walnut Victorian drop leaf kitchen table is a classic design. Similar tables brought $75-$100 in recent auctions. Bonus: Smaller basic tables are easier to squeeze into limited floor space.
Our second reader sent a photo of an imposing Victorian bookcase desk combo. We have no measurements, but can see that it’s a tall piece with a base cabinet having two hinged doors. Top that with a pull down desk surface and three small drawers. Add a 4-shelf bookcase fronted with paned glass doors.
The piece is mid-late 1800s, probably American, and looks like burled walnut, perhaps veneer.
The unit is currently in the Southern part of the U.S. — a plus, because the type sells best there.
Again, our suggestion is to research recent auction results, as stated above. We found similar pieces that sold recently at auction for $650-$2,500. This is a very good example and should be shopped accordingly.
Here’s where things get tricky. Some auctions prefer electronic inquiries, but will accept photos. If ease of working with computers is a problem, have someone in the family help. Research is also infinitely easier with computer skills.
In sum, having determined that her items are of modest value, the first reader should approach a good area auction that sells vintage household furniture.
The bookcase desk needs to be shopped to a local auction with a record of selling good Victorian furniture. Check out their results with similar pieces before you consign.
See what I mean about checking out the territory? Do your homework so you don’t set yourself up to be sorry!
Danielle Arnet welcomes questions from readers. She cannot respond to each one individually, but will answer those of general interest in her column. Send e-mail to smartcollector@comcast.net.

