A new Arizona law prohibits the city of Tucson from enforcing its ban on political campaign signs in public rights of way.
The law was sponsored by Rep. David Gowan, R-Sierra Vista, and signed in April by Gov. Jan Brewer. Gowan did not return calls for comment.
State Rep. Ted Vogt R-Tucson, said he voted for the bill because it creates sign-code consistency among jurisidictions and promotes freedom of speech.
"I can certainly understand folks get upset," he said, while adding, "If our First Amendment protects anything, it's political speech."
Former City Councilman Brent Davis, who was later a longtime member of the City Sign Code Committee, called the new state law a tragedy and said it was passed to personally benefit the state lawmakers who created it.
"The Legislature has consistently passed laws to override local jurisdictions while complaining about the federal government doing it to them," he said. "It's pretty two-faced. In any election year, it almost assures the trashing of our community with political signs."
People are also reading…
The city first prohibited political signs from public rights of way in 1992 but generally ignored violations unless they created a traffic hazard or were a danger to pedestrians.
But by the 2000 presidential campaign season, the proliferation of signs jamming the rights of way, and the number of citizen complaints about them, were so great that the City Council ordered strict enforcement of the law starting with the 2001 city election.
Since then city workers have removed thousands of signs from rights of way and taken them to an impound yard where their owners could reclaim them, or leave them to be destroyed after the election.
Gowan's bill makes it a Class 2 misdemeanor to remove any political campaign sign placed in a public right of way. Signs may be posted 60 days before primary elections and left standing until 15 days after the general election. Under the new law, a sign may be removed only if its presence creates an immediate danger to public safety.
The city ban is aimed primarily at city-owned property flanking major streets, particularly at intersections.
It also applies to sidewalks, posts, poles, hydrants, bridges and trees that touch public property.
City Attorney Michael Rankin told the council about the change at its June 28 study session and advised them he doubts the city could win a lawsuit challenging the law.
City Clerk Roger Randolph told the council that candidates have been asked "out of the goodness of their hearts" to honor the city code - and the clearly stated preference of the public - by not placing their campaign signs in the right of way.
On StarNet: Go to azstarnet.com/news/local/govt-and-politics to read more about local and state government news.
Matthew Casey is a University of Arizona journalism student apprenticing at the Star. He can be reached at 573-4142 or starapprentice@azstarnet.com

