PHOENIX — Challengers to Arizona’s denial of driver’s licenses to “dreamers” want internal documents and testimony — perhaps even from Gov. Jan Brewer — in their legal bid to prove her actions are illegal.
Attorney Victor Viramontes of the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund contends the Brewer administration is improperly hiding behind claims of privilege to avoid answering questions about how she and the Department of Administration came up with the policy. He wants U.S. District Judge David Campbell to order both ADOT and Brewer’s staffs to produce documents leading up to the policy change.
The move is getting a fight from the governor’s lawyers.
In his own filings with the court, Douglas Northup, lead counsel for Brewer, charges that MALDEF has been “asking blatantly inappropriate questions aimed at invading the attorney-client privilege.” He wants Campbell to rebuff Viramontes.
People are also reading…
What the judge rules could determine the ultimate outcome of the case.
Viramontes said the question of whether those in the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, known as “dreamers,” are entitled to Arizona licenses goes beyond the simple issue of whether they are authorized by federal law to be in this country.
He pointed out that the lawsuit is based in large part on MALDEF’s contention that Brewer and her staff decided ahead of time they wanted to deny licenses to DACA recipients, but wanted to do it in such a way that the policy change would not affect others in the country illegally. That, Viramontes said, would violate constitutional requirements to treat all people equally.
Earlier this year, Campbell said there appeared to be some basis for that equal-protection claim. So ADOT again altered the policy in a way that Viramontes argues was similarly designed mainly to keep licenses out of the hands of DACA recipients.
“Under the equal-protection analysis, your motivation is one of the key factors that you have to evaluate to figure out if they’re discriminating,” he said. “By denying us this discovery, they’re keeping us from proving our case.”
Viramontes wants internal memos and emails between ADOT and Brewer staff members exchanged ahead of the policy changes. And he wants those involved in changing the policy to answer questions about how it came about.
So far, Viramontes has questioned ADOT Director John Halikowski and several others. He said, however, that it may become necessary to take a deposition from Brewer herself.
Northup told Campbell there are reasons the judge should reject Viramontes’ request. One is the issue of attorney-client privilege.
But Viramontes said it appears the lawyers were doing more than simply providing advice as requested.
“It looks like the attorneys were present at all the meetings or did all the work, one of the two,” he said. “And they can’t shield the entirety of governmental work just by having a lawyer there.”
Brewer’s other claim is that any internal discussions are protected because they are part of the “deliberative process.”
Northup said government agencies are entitled to withhold documents “that reflect advisory opinions, recommendations and deliberations comprising part of a process by which government decisions and policies are formulated.”
Viramontes said all that’s irrelevant here.
“In the context of a discrimination case, there is no ‘deliberative process,’ ” he said. Viramontes told the judge that Brewer and ADOT are trying to have it both ways.
“Defendants claim that their actions were not motivated by an improper purpose, yet at the same time seek to shield documents and conversations regarding the bases for their decisions to prohibit driver’s licenses to the plaintiffs and other deferred action recipients,” he wrote.
Brewer’s original executive order in August 2012 concluded that the Obama administration’s DACA program did not amount to legally authorizing anyone to be in this country.
She said the program simply allows those who arrived as children to remain and work without fear that the Department of Homeland Security will seek to have them deported. And that, Brewer said, still leaves those who qualify for DACA outside the requirements of a 1996 state law saying licenses are available only to those whose presence is “authorized by federal law.”
Earlier this year, though, Campbell noted that Arizona was still granting licenses to those in various other “deferred action” programs. That, he said, opened the door for MALDEF to argue equal-protection violations.
In response, ADOT rescinded its own long-standing practice of granting licenses to those in these other groups, including victims of domestic violence, who the DHS have allowed to remain in this country.
Gubernatorial press aide Andrew Wilder did not respond to requests for comment.

