"Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)” may have an unwieldy title, but it’s the most charming musical of the year.
Two powerhouse performers tell the story of a young Brit journeying to New York to attend his father’s wedding. The bride’s sister picks him up at the airport, and the two begin sharing their stories.
Sam Tutty is a livewire as Dougal, peppering every story with references to old movies. He doesn’t just want to meet his father for the first time, he wants to see every tourist attraction from the Statue of Liberty to the Golden Gate Bridge. His driver, Robyn (Christiani Pitts), doesn’t know how to temper his enthusiasm. She’s asked to pick up the wedding cake. Naturally, he goes along.
Robin (Christiani Pitts, left) and Dougal (Sam Tutty) get Chinese food after a wild night out in the city.
In the course of that trip, the two sing about their hopes and dreams and admit what has changed their lives. The revelations are often heartbreaking. As told in the smart songs by Jim Barne and Kit Buchan, there’s no reason to care if that cake ever does get to the wedding.
People are also reading…
Nimbly directed and choreographed by Tim Jackson, “Two Strangers” unfolds on a rotating baggage claim turntable. Luggage opens to become a Chinese restaurant, the Plaza hotel, a coffee shop.
When the two strangers become friends, we discover the truth about their families. We also realize they have simple needs and big hearts.
Tears fall during several scenes, but only because Tutty and Pitts are so skilled at being real. They sing with passion, move with purpose and make “Two Strangers” seem like the biggest show on Broadway.
He’s a surprise — and a welcome addition to New York theater. She’s a triple threat who could figure into any number of shows this season. Put them together, and they’re unstoppable. Tonys aside, this show could run for years.
