Episode 267: Gossip has a bad reputation. We associate it with rumors, betrayal and talking behind someone’s back. But what if talking about other people also serves an important social purpose?
This week on “The Ethical Life,” the conversation begins in an unlikely place: “Survivor.” After watching the reality show for the first time in more than a decade, host Scott Rada was struck by how much of the game revolves around relationships. Contestants build alliances, decide whom they can trust, and constantly exchange information about people who aren’t part of the conversation.
But is everyday life really so different?
Research suggests that talking about other people can help us learn whom to trust, strengthen social connections and encourage cooperation. Host Rick Kyte argues that such conversations can also help us understand why people behave the way they do. Talking through someone else’s choices may allow us to consider their motivations, develop empathy and decide how we should respond.
People are also reading…
Of course, not every conversation about an absent person is harmless. The hosts consider where the ethical boundaries should be, particularly when someone shares information that is true but personal. Does a person retain some ownership over news about their own life? Should confidentiality be assumed even when someone never explicitly asks for it? And how much should our motives matter when deciding whether to share something?
The discussion also explores how these conversations can reinforce social norms. Knowing that friends, relatives and co-workers may eventually talk about our behavior can influence the choices we make. Kyte distinguishes between guilt, which comes from violating our own standards, and shame, which comes from worrying about how others will judge us.
Perhaps the problem, then, isn’t that people talk about one another. It’s what they say, why they say it and what they hope to accomplish.
Scott Rada is a digital strategist with Lee Enterprises, and Richard Kyte is the director of the D.B. Reinhart Institute for Ethics in Leadership at Viterbo University in La Crosse, Wisconsin. He is also the author of "Finding Your Third Place: Building Happier Communities (and Making Great Friends Along the Way)." This article was prepared with the help of AI technology using information collected and verified by journalists.
